Shoe Choices - YouLookFab Forum

I saw these nine west sandals when Shannon and I were shopping and tried them on today. They fit well and felt pretty good but I saw another pair online that are very similar. I would like to get opinions.

The first pair are the ones I saw last weekend and the second pair is the online choice. The first pair has the advantage that I've tried them on but the only downside is the back of the heel. I often find these don't fit as well as they should. They felt okay but I think the adjustable strap of the second pair is an advantage.

The first pair is a nice neutral (they come in coral too) but the second pair may work better with the grey cropped pant as they are lighter and will blend more.

I am adding a poll. Yay is first pair and Nay is second pair.

This post has 2 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

14 years ago

Irene

Veteran

I like both! Depends on your priorities, skin tone and high heel bearing!

Kristin L

I like the tan pair better, but it all depends on what you are going to wear it with.

Transcona Shannon

Wow - this is a tough one Dianthus. The first pair is lovely, especially since I've seen them IRL. But I hear what you're saying about the second pair maybe being a better colour with your new slouchy pants and more adjustability.

If you're picking a pair to go specifically with the your new slouchy pants, I would go with the second pair.

Suz

(website)

Ditto what Shannon said. I know what you mean about those heels on #1; for me they can be a fit problem, too. And lots of rubbing.

But both are super shoes. In terms of looks, (shhhh) get both!

ManidipaM

What Suz (and Shannon) said!

Deborah

I adore the 2nd pair Dianthus. And I could see them working perfectly with the slouchy pants.

jayne

I think #2 is just a bit more stylish and I think the buckle is a great advantage. Plus I like the color better. All Nay for me

lyn*

I concur with Suz ... get both

CocoLion

The second "nay" pair.

brown

Active Member

Wow! Amazing pair of shoes...I love those pair of shoes...:)

cheryle (Dianthus)

Thanks everyone. I am trying to buy fewer shoes and wear them more so I think I will get the second pair. The big advantage of the first pair is I can get them locally but I should have the second pair in a week and the way the weather is going, that is soon enough.

Claudia

I really like both pairs as well. Can't go wrong with these. Beautiful.

Category