It's really interesting to hear about your successes and failures. Thanks for chiming in. Jaime, when I get a good ft with a Zara shoe, it's remarkably good for me! Can't wait to see what has worked for you (and where you have sourced it.)
Nadya, I remember your post about that maxi skirt. It's so pretty. And I love both pants, too, and can see how and why they would become instant favourites. The Munro sandals also look great.
cat2, that's really interesting -- that what worked well was footwear/ bag complements. I can see that since in summer they really are often our outfit completers, especially for work outfits. You just feel more together when you have a pair that marry well, whether they match or just coordinate really well.
Lisa, my first Cole Haans came from the Bay on sale. The others came from the Cole Haan Canada site and I also got them on sale. The platform version of the knit oxford is really good -- not as instantly comfy as the regular version, but easy to wear (wore it today for a long walk -- no issues, except it got wet, since it was pouring rain, ha!).
The grey Zero grands are great except I don't care for the insole as much as in the Original Grands -- which is okay, since it's removable/ replaceable. These are basically sneaker subs for me -- not for running, obviously -- but I wore them for very long city and trail walks in San Francisco and got nary a blister, which for me is nothing short of a miracle. Plus, they are washable. TBH, the loafers do not match the oxfords in quality/ fit but I bought them strictly as comfy house shoes -- I don't do so well with slippers -- it wasn't worth it to send them back and they will get wear at home.
Style Fan, you are a queen of Birks! You have a lot of pairs. I hope you can find a replacement for the Sanctuary pants -- i can easily imagine how well they would work in your wardrobe.
Angie, what a shame about the pumps -- oy! That is very frustrating indeed. It really isn't easy to know with footwear, is it? We try and try, but ... I also struggle wth molded footbeds like Birks or similar...I do have a pair of Ecco flip flops from last summer that create that difficulty for me. I wear them, but they are strictly house slippers. I would not purchase again.
Carol, that's a great skirt. It looks like a cotton/ linen blend or something. And gored skirts like that feel really breezy and easy to dress up or down. Not surprised it has worked well for you.
Sal, I love your lilac merino and your wool coat. Gorgeous pieces! The coat will be in your closet for years and will earn its wear. As for the merino, I think you and Angie and I might be the Queen, the Princess, and the Duchess of Merino on the forum -- we live in the perfect climate for it!
Hard to say about the coatigan. Sometimes items like that slide back into favour. I'd hang on for a while for sure.
Irina, that's soooo interesting about the full length pants. I prefer full lengths in the cooler temps and mostly wore crops all summer but will return to full lengths in fall. If the MD pants don't feel great next year, maybe you could have them cropped in order to get more wear from them?
Dee, you did so well with those Simons tees. I especially love the blue, black white one with the geometric pattern. Striking and unusual! I hear you on the shorts -- I once had a pair in that style. I was in my early 20s and slim. My neighbour caught sight of me in the elevator and asked if I were pregnant. It was the waist gathers...
Carla, I love that hoodie and love how it comes out in summer and works with just about everything. I can also see why the shorts and camp shirts would quickly become favourites. Love the little nylon bag, too. I keep wanting something like that, and then realize I also need a place for my water bottle, which is why I keep on carrying knapsacks....
Suntiger, that's a great reminder about sunnies. Ii wear mine constantly, too. Sal has a whole mini wardrobe of sunglasses and I think I could also do with a few pairs. High five on the ripskirt! I didn't wear mine much this year but I haven't given up on it, either.
Helena, a dud free summer is brilliant! Brava for that! You have been planning and shopping well!