What a great analysis, Colette. I am still puzzled, though, because I think 14.5" is a pretty average calf width -- it's what many boots measure in the calf, anyway, if I am not mistaken. And I just measured my knees and they are about 14" (this is in relation to a 13.5" calf, which sounds about the same, proportionately.) Admittedly, I do have issues with my own knees, but let's not go there!
So I'm really curious.
You know, for years I believed my calves were fat. Yes. And I endured the pained eye rolling from some sales associates as I fruitlessly tried to do up knee high boots.
But guess what? My calves are actually on the slim side. Which makes sense because I'm not tall -- they're not slim proportionately, really. Just normal. What they are is SHORTER than average so their curve comes in a different place. They curve out where the boots are going in.
I wonder if there is something similar going on here. Are you taller than average or shorter than average or are your legs shorter or longer than is typical for your size?