So the upshot of my terrier-like coat stalk is that 4 sizes of the EF sweater coat are enroute to me. SM, PP, PS and my usual size finally popped back at 6 am today the XS. Yesterday got to try on the first which was size small. This is a unique piece. There is a modern but also a retro 1950's vibe. Think Jackie O and Camelot. It's a dressy lady coat, quiet, understated but edgy because of the modern cut and leather sleeves. The mock neck begs for a formal pin. This could easily be worn as a coat dress or indoor blazer if you run cold, as I do. What it's not designed for is heavy outdoor use. I think that's what threw some of the people who bought it. Pockets would have added bulk, the material is substantial but light, it's not felted wool and not at all a blanket coat. Early fall, spring, indoor winter or under another swing or cocoon coat. The coat is a tightly woven wool, feels like a very substantial merino with a smooth nap. Snaps are heavy gauge and substantial so I would be careful in using them as not to overly stress the fabric. Light but warm. The body is A-line but with a fitted shoulder but sleeves are roomy enough to allow under layers. I think this is incredibly unique. Dressy, formal (but can easily swing casual), ladylike, modern. Religious, conference, winter event, evening coat for anything but most formal, dressy casual, evening out, work for a more formal environment. I haven't seen anything like it before. The small was a size up from my usual but the shoulders were just a little roomy. The reviewer who said the body was "huge" are not accustomed to a-line styling (think EF dressy silk coats, and KS franny coats - it's a 1950's mod vibe updated) and is best appreciated closed and in motion. Snaps stop about 1/2 down which is graceful. This is one of the pieces that is missing in my wardrobe - the missing link between dressy cardi and corporate/edgy blazer. I will try on the PP, PS, and XS and see which gives the best fit but if your style runs formal and you like black this is a unique piece which might be a good investment. For what it's worth, it was worth the aggravation and stalking!!