Do any of you know what Nordies does with returned makeup? Last night one of the Bobbi Brown SAs used a gel eyeliner on me and I loved it enough that I bought a jar. Later in the evening, my eyes felt gritty, and this morning they were red and glassy. I'm pretty confident it was a reaction to an ingredient in the liner.

I'm planning on returning the eyeliner as the jar I bought is unopened, but I do feel bad that they may toss out a perfectly good product.