I have always wondered about those services. The white is HEAVENLY on you! I love the blue and white lace as well but you look dreamy in all white!

They are so different, it's hard to choose, but I'll go for #2.

That renting service sounds fantastic.

I vote for the white because it just seems to float on you and looks dreamy. Is this the renting service that was pitched on Dragon's Den a while ago? It certainly seems to be a good idea and their service to get the dresses to you was pretty amazing. Keep us posted.

Yes, Runs that same service. They are called Rent Frock Repeat. SO far I'm impressed. The dresses came with a little package with dress tape, a deodorant removing sponge and some coupons. You also get to keep the hangers (woo hoo!).

I vote 1 (the blue). So gorgeous!
The fit of the white is not a 10!

I like #1 better as it is more unexpected. The second one is also nice, so you really can't go wrong!

I think both are stunning on you. I would probably go with number 2 as I prefer the longer length. Excited to see what you decide.

I think you need the spanx to see if the cling will disappear (maybe it will make dress 2 look better from the side and back).

Apart from that, I agree with Angie, I prefer the look of dress 2 in front view only but the blue is nice from all angles. If you can't smooth out the dress from the other angles, my opinion is go with the blue!

I'm surprised at how nice the white one looks. I really thought is would be too short on you. They both look good to my eye, so I'd say pick whichever one feels the best. You'll look smashing in either one.

Hi Nicole --

Thanks for reporting back!

I like them both on you and think either will make a great choice, but if you want fun + drama my vote is for the all-white!

[And for better or worse I find Spanx makes all the difference with this style of dress...glad you're going to experiment.]