I'm looking for a closed toe white pump and like the look of the Odynna for summer because it's not completely enclosed, i.e. I like its sling back style, and that it has some perforations.

When I tried my typical size 8.5 M, the toe box stopped at the widest part of my foot and unfortunately digs into the side of my foot in a painful way. I wasn't sure I could stretch it out to fit. Does anyone know if it would be worth ordering the size 9? It's only the right shoe, and my right foot is slightly larger than my left. I'm worried they would be too large. (Here's where I need a size 8.5 for my left foot and a size 9 for my right foot!).

Any suggestions for similar shoes? I think I have a regular to high volume foot because I have very stiff high arches, but my heel and ankles are narrow.

I can wear heels, but don't like to go much higher than 3" for shoes I plan to wear to work. They are too impractical.