I am madly in love with #4, but need some guidance on how to wear them. Aida's suggestion is really smart, and I am going to try it with all four. But the OTKs seem hardest to style, unless I just wear them with anything. Suggestions? I love #2 but #1 (non-black, suede and lace-up) fills a lot of holes.

On another note, on boot #2, the laces are super-long now that I've tightened them. Any ideas on how to shorten laces short of having to re-lace the entire boot? They zip so the laces are only for decoration...

I would choose #1 if they really fill so many holes. Second pair would be #2, I just love the look! They are fab! If you choose #4, I would leave out #1 and take the second ones.

It all depends on what sort of laces you have, if you want to shorten them. You can simply cut leather ones. For synthetic braided ones are these little plastic ends best. Cut them and close the plastic with a caliper.

FWIW, I like #1 and #2 best. (Haven't read the other comments!). They are KILLER.

I vote pass on #3.

I can't see #4 closely enough to determine fit, especially since your skinnies are a little baggy tucked into them. But they have potential

Angie, I will post some photos and close-ups today of #4. It's hard to decide between #1 and #2.. #3 is going back (*sob*)/

I vote for #1, they are drool worthy. #2 looks a bit similar to #1 so I vote return. #3 I am happy to hear they are going back, they were a bit chunky on your feet. #4 I'll keep an eye on for more photos.