Still looking for oxfords that suit my comfort and style criteria, which I outlined here and refined here.

Here's an update.
After I had ordered the Paul Green Addly in black, it became available in taupe (called "truffle"). So I ordered them when I returned the black ones.

Then I found some others to try, and they arrived today: Fly London Yif, in "sludge" suede, an olive brown color; Dr. Martens 3989 Brogue in pewter spectra patent; Seychelles Welcome Back, in pewter metallic.

In the meantime, I tried on the Halogen Daphne in gray at Nordstrom. it was cute, but not all that comfy. The leather was pretty stiff.

I also found the Kate Spade Pella flat brogue in a color that translates to "lead." I have not ordered it.

Here are the ones I've brought home, styled somewhat. The two first outfits are ones I would typically expect to wear with oxfords. The harem pants are a wild card--wouldn't expect to wear them with oxfords, but if they go, it's a bonus. The skinny pants outfit I'm not really liking, but I would wear the pants with oxfords--just probably not with the tee tucked in as I have it here. The skirt is a tryout--I have not yet worn skirts with low/flat oxfords.

The oxfords:
Paul Green Addly, in taupe
Seychelles Welcome Back, in pewter metallic
Dr. Martens 3989 Brogue in pewter spectra patent
Fly London Yif, in sludge suede

Here are each of the five looks, worn with each of the four oxfords (I've tried combining photos, but haven't got it down yet--sorry!):

1-4: navy slouchy pants, gray print tee.
5-8: olive chinos, gray print tee.
9-12: black harem pants, blues reptile print silk tee.
13-16: stone skinny pants, blues reptile print silk tee, navy linen knit vest.
17-20: denim layered-front skirt, blues reptile print silk tee.

I'm sure I will return the Doc Martens. I love the idea of them, but these are too big, and as much as I love them on others, I suspect they are not "me." What do you think, though? Should I try another size?
I'm pretty set on returning the Fly Londons. They feel and look like they'd be close to duplicating my sneakers. And they are a funny fit at the back of the heel. I think I'd like to try a sandal in this brand.

What do you all think of the Paul Greens or the Seychelles for me?

Should I order the Kate Spades to try, too?

Thanks for looking, and I'd love to hear your feedback.

This post has 20 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.