Thank you all so much for responding.
FWIW I liked the more fitted tops too. However I'll need to find non- fitted ones that work too, as sometimes it's just too hot for anything else..
I noticed that number 7 was polarizing. I like it as a top, and I think it looks great tucked, but personally didn't like it with the shorts. I also felt like the whole outfit was too low contrast.
Thanks Robyn. It is nice to have some built in detail on hot weather clothes isn't it, when layering isn't an option
Angie, thanks. I thought mine were shorter than yours, but looking at the pictures they are about the same length. Nice to have your approval (teenage daughters are not so keen!) I agree with your least favourite list.I'm trying to remember if you have a post on outfits with shorts this length. - I'll have a look after.
Helena - yes flowy is often what I need, thanks for the half tuck suggestion.
Thanks Stag. Interestingly I'm think the pink one is the one I'd be least likely to wear. Too much likelihood of showing skin. I think if I was going to do that I'd go for a higher rise bottom.
Zaeobi - thanks for the breakdown of those details - very helpful. You have pinpointed the exact issue I worry about with the outfit - the vertical dimensions and how it cuts the torso. I agree with all your points (except that I might be too inhibited to wear number 5 - see above!)
Thanks Kellygirl and Slim Cat.
Lesley I think you have really got into the nub - this outfit WOULD look better with woven tops. And I'm realising more and more that hot weather woven tops are a real wardrobe hole for me right now. In fact I'm planning to go to the shops today and see if I can rectify the situation!