Thanks for all the replies, very interesting that some of you prefer #1 and some prefer #2. I think I will go with both, using the grey sweater and returning the black.
Traci yes you've got it, a sleeveless sweater is easier to layer over than one wiht thicker sleeves.
Colette, the necklace is actually wood beads that has been in my jewelry box forever. I wore it a lot at some point in the distant past. I hardly ever wear it lately but keep it for that time it will be just right.
Lady I could do the red beads with any of these outfits. And yes, I'd probably do opaque tights instead of what I'm wearing here. You are right, it does seem that the grey one shows the knit texture better than the black.
Sally - wow, "you look better than the model"...that really makes my day!!!
bj1111 yes length is so crucial. This piece is a bit of an experiment and was quite inexpensive so I'm not being too picky about the length for a change.
Thanks aviamariah, aquamarine and staysfit.
Aliona I tend to agree, it's a bit better over pants than a skirt.
Cerinda I could try black tees & beads by trying not to go too close to solid black. Hmm..I have a black blouse with sheer sleeves, that could work for a dressier look.
TorontoGirl I could do the beads as a bracelet except that the elastic is completely shot and I'd have to restring it.. I think I agree with you that the sweater looks better on it's own.