I happily bought Neutrogena’s wax-free mascara until they discontinued it. Now I’m looking for a replacement - something low-key that darkens and enhances without clumping of flakiness. I tried Neutrogena’s suggested replacement, called Healthy Lengths I think - mucho clumps and Twiggy overkill. Then Revlon Fabulash, which at least doesn’t clump as much but smears a lot. Next was the classic Maybelline Great Lash, which wasn’t bad but left dark marks under the eyes after a while, even with the waterproof version.

Any suggestions? I would prefer something waterproof because I wear contacts. Department store brands are ok if they really work.