Goldenpig: I think the bomber looks great with the skirt. My one thought is that you might wear a little heel to dress up the look more deliberately, if the bomber made you feel a little casual for work. I think your jewelry choices were excellent for dressing up the outfit. Also, with the tucked shirt, you kept the look shapely and feminine, too--far from your fear of dumpy.
La Belle: The jacket is beautiful on you. Yes, you do look like a million bucks--at least! I had the same thought, you could try wearing it with jeans sometimes (for a date or to go shopping, maybe) instead of saving it for super special occasions.
Mona: I like how you've styled the necklace. It's perfect with that top and sweater, and love the white jeans with the blues. However, I wonder if it's the length and style that make it hard to wear. I don't wear my necklaces that length, either, unless I can double them and wear them shorter. Is that the case for you?
Shedev: I have those oxfords in brown! I like them as styled with those jeans. I wear mine like that, with my boot cut jeans that have shrunk too much to wear with heels anymore. And I love wearing them with skinnies, so you might try that, too. I like the top on you as well, and I think you could wear it under jackets or by itself, with jeans or black trousers.
Pastrygirl: Love the first outfit on you! But if it's not comfortable, it doesn't pass my personal test for wearing. I just don't get out the door in uncomfortable clothes. Your last outfit is a keeper, too, especially if you felt more like yourself in it.
Karie: hooray for animal print as a neutral! And the jacket is fab on you. Agree the blue skirt is fun for casual wear.
Joy: I like the checked shirt best with the two jackets. Just dynamite! I LOVE your use of it for pattern-mixing. To me it seems a little preppy with the citron jeans, and it's very cute that way, but I wonder if that's the style you're going for. Personally I'm attracted to your eclecticizing of it! (But you might guess that, coming from me, huh?)
K, you are looking so, so fab in the third outfit! What a contrast. Yes, unfortunately, the lace and tweed is just not the right fit or shape to achieve the same level of fabness.
Elle, I think your look is perfectly boho. If the hat doesn't work for summer when you like to be more boho, then you might need to swap it for a lighter version. I'd hang on to the jeans; I've been seeing some boyfriend-style boot cuts, and these might work that way--unless you need some slouchy cutoffs sooner!
Thanks to all who gave me feedback on the tunic. I'm glad it's working (more or less) with the skirt I have. A pinafore look I don't really want, but a skirt in the same color is probably not going to fall into my life. (Even fabric options aren't that ideal, alas.) K, I really appreciate the link--that gives me a great image to try to copy.