Oh my goodness. These are BOTH wonderful! I'm glad you went for the Clarks. I would love a pair of those, too!
I adore my Reports. They are SOOOOOOO comfortable. And I am not a girl who wears heels. I can wear them for 10 hours straight!! And I don't think weather's an issue, because I weatherproofed them. I wouldn't wear them in dirty slush, but I DO wear them on sunny days and slightly damp days, without question. With socks, tights, micro fishnets and bare-footed.
However, as others have said, the wide ankle opening is a bit of an acquired taste. On the positive side, it makes them more wearable in somewhat warmer weather. That is to say, I wear them with bare feet and they feel as cool as most shoes. I wouldn't do that/couldn't do that with most boots and booties.
On the negative side, some skinnies do not work well with this boot (although straight legs, boot cuts, and wider skinnies work perfectly) and if you have a slim ankle, they stand out from the ankle. They do on me, but for whatever reason I think it looks okay.
Having said that, I'd adore the lace-up. And I can't wait to see you wearing those Clarks!!!!.
Where did you order from?