I had no idea REI had such a great return policy, or an annual garage sale.
Reneeb, you are so kind to worry about returning shoes that you cannot wear after a year. Norstrom's encourages you to use their wonderful customer service, and it works for them in making loyal customers. They have told me over and over to try things out and just return if it doesn't work.
My daughter had a pair of pants for about 2 years in her closet that she just couldn't wear. They still had the tags on which is important to help customer service figure out how much she paid. She was afraid to approach customer service, so I did it for her, no problems at all.
Nordstrom's is making alot of money from me and my family and they treat us as if they are glad we are their customers. This has been working for the Nordstrom family for 2 or 3 generations.
Still, your reluctance to take advantage shows great character.