Relatively new member here, but have lurked forever. In general about me if it helps: apple shape, currently losing weight (yes!), so somewhere between an XL in regular, size 16, and 0X/14W/16W depending on the item and the fit. Long torso and short legs! Shoe size 9.5. High arches and pretty average foot width.

Here is what I tried this time around:
Caslon Colorblock tee in yellow: nice weekend piece. Keeping.
Halogen Strip Knit top: a little short. Interesting fabric and I do like it. If I keep it, I'll need to wear something under it to keep from showing my mid-section.
Halogen puff sleeve sweater in yellow: does not fit me at all like the model. Scratchy. Going back.
Treasure and Bond Sporty Striped Sweater: very cute, I actually like the detail on the shoulders. I had a cardigan from Halogen (I think) that had a similar pleating and loved it. Keep.
Foxcroft Fall Tartan Plaid Shirt: on the fence if I really need this. I love the colors, and it fits well.
NYDJ Stretch Knit Trousers: these fit my proportionally larger waist and smaller hips so well! They need to be shortened for me to wear them, though. Typical of NYJD for me. Think I'll keep them.
NYDJ Betty Ankle Pants: These for some reason fit a little less well, but the ankle thing is so trendy and usually works with my short legs just fine. On the fence.
Pikolinos Oxfords: posted in another thread, but 40 is waaaay too small. I'm very sad they have to go back. A 41 is also unlikely to fit.
Zella Plank pants: Tight in the wrong places and loose in others. A little too long for me as well. They had potential on the screen.
Rebecca Minkoff Koso booties in Red: I am SO keeping these and am going to wear them every day. That is all. I love red shoes, and these fit the bill. I'm a bit of a straight leg pant kinda gal, so these will go well with my current pant selections.
Josef Seibel Caspian Sneaker in Grigio-- had a pair of these awhile ago that were worn out and replaced with the same color. I think these also run small, so a 41 it is.