NAS Jackets (with pics) - Which are the keepers? Updated with styling photos. - YouLookFab Forum

Category

Anniversary Sale

Welcome! Read about what to wear and how to wear it on the YLF Blog. Join the YLF Forum to ask specific questions or just chat about fashion and personal style. Or check out the curated list of things we love in YLF Finds.

Outfits Ensembles Trends Advice

NAS Jackets (with pics) - Which are the keepers? Updated with styling photos.

julesegr

I ordered several jackets from NAS with the hopes of keeping a few. I'm an "updated classic" kind of dresser so these all fit my style. While I love the polish a jacket brings to an outfit, I also don't tend to reach for them enough, so I'm turning to you all to help minimize the mistakes.

In order to try to assist in the comparisons, I'm wearing the same white shell and jeans in all the photos. I tried to keep the same pose, too. I'll put some observations below.

1. Veronica Beard Moto, size 10. This turned out to be a little less structured than I expected. It's also lighter weight, too, so I wonder if I can use it as an indoor jacket during the winter months. I do like how it's a statement topper that "makes" a simple outfit.
2. J Crew Tipped Merino Sweater Blazer, size M. I think this is a keeper. It's comfortable and just about as easy to wear as a sweater would be.
3. Lafayette 148 Tansy Suede Jacket, size M. This was the first thing my SA suggested this year. She's always looking for that one splurge-y, "forever" piece during the NAS (and it's usually Lafayette). We had to order it, though, so I never got her take on it in person. This is definitely a quality piece. It's unlined suede and feels (and smells!) heavenly. It's very comfortable, almost like shirt, but I'm not sure of the boxy, drapey shape. Obviously it needs to be perfect as it's very spendy.
4. Treasure and Bond Moto, size M: This is a classic black moto, which I don't own and have been looking for forever. Leather feels nice and it's very slightly oversized. This seems like a no-brainer, if one believes that everyone needs a black moto.
5. J Crew Regent Houndstooth Blazer, size 10. I love how classic it is, but it is a little scratchy. Another one that "makes" a simple outfit but isn't as comfortable as some.
6. Rag and Bone Redgrave Piped Blazer, size L. This is another SA pick that I go back and forth on. Looking at the photos, I think it looks cool, but it definitely doesn't fit me like it does on the model and I'm having some trouble getting past that. It's also relatively lightweight so it might also just be a fall/spring piece and it's also rather expensive.

Any and all feedback is welcome!

This post has 6 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

Veronica Beard Benson Moto Jacket

View Info

Top Pick

15

J.Crew J.Crew Tipped Merino Wool Sweater Blazer

View Info

Top Pick

4

Lafayette 148 New York Tansy Suede Jacket

View Info

Top Pick

5

Treasure&Bond Leather Moto Jacket

View Info

Top Pick

3

J.Crew J.Crew Regent Houndstooth Plaid Blazer

View Info

Top Pick

4

Rag & Bone Redgrave Piped Blazer

View Info

Top Pick

2

Anniversary Sale

40 replies

Latest reply was from julesegr

Suz

(website)

Veteran

Wow, what a fab collection of jackets!

It's nice to see some that I had not even noticed or considered, so thank you for these reviews.

First question, what type of jacket are you really looking for, to complete your fall outfits or add to your closet?

Second question, which ones would you really reach for?

Which colours are most represented/ needed in your closet? Which are your core neutrals?

It's a bit tough to judge the fit on some of these or the flattery since we don't have your whole face/ skin tone. But for what it is worth...it looks like all would need sleeve alterations. Is that possible with some more easily than others? If so, that might be a rule out.

Second, can you style as you would hope to wear? Although the same background is great for determining fit and doing a comparison on that basis, it's tough to know if a specific cut works without the support act.

On the basis of what I see here -- and only that -- my votes go to 1, 4, and 6.

KnittingGene

How fun! I echo Suz' comments above. #2 and 6 jump out at me. But I think the question of expense of sleeve alterations is a good one - looks like 6 has a cuff so that might be fairly expensive as would the leather Moto. After considering Suz' questions of need and color, maybe you could style a couple of them again for us. Also, I note that twice you mention a jacket would elevate an outfit by itself. It seems like that idea is calling to you so you might pay attention to that idea.

kerry

Veteran

I like the first and last ones best.

Kathie

Veteran

I really like both the tipped/piped ones, #2/#6. They look sharp. Completely agree that the J Crew one is a keeper, especially if you think it will be easy to wear. The VB seems a bit long in the sleeves, but also potentially good. The Lafayette and the moto are hard for me to get a sense of the details from the pictures.

Mochi

Veteran

Love the first one on you. Sorry (perhaps) for not liking the spendy one, #3, but it just appears too shapeless to me.

julesegr

Thanks for the responses so far. You all raise some good points about sleeve hemming and the minimally-styled photos.

I can get reimbursed alterations from Nordstrom, so that helps. The VB is the only truly tricky one to shorten, as I believe there are zips involved. I am not sure it can be done. The R&B can likely be done, but the SA was also a fan of just turning them back, in a louche kind of way.

As for your questions, Suz, I think I'm just looking for some updates, not so much to fill holes. My wardrobe neutrals are black, olive, burgundy, and some gray. I wear a ton of navy, but less in the winter.

KnittingGene, you raise a good point about wanting a piece to elevate an outfit in itself. There's nothing easier, or more my style, than wearing jeans, booties, a nice layering T (in black or a muted stripe) and throwing on a 3rd piece.

I'll try to style these up a bit more and see if I can get some additional photos, but I'm pretty sure the men in my family won't be willing photographers!

Anonymous

It's hard to judge the fits but my favorites are 1,4, and 5. Numbers 2 and 6 seem a little costume-y and 3 is a good idea but the details of the front closure are a little weak.

Anonymous

Re: photo 6.
It looks a little weird on the model and much better on you.

I'm not familiar with your personal style, but the ones I think have a snaz-factor are the VB Moto, the leather jacket, and either the Rag and Bone jacket or the JCrew grey jacket (both have the same vibe).

kellygirl

Veteran

1 and 4 are my faves. Right off the bat, the grey tipped jacket looks big through the arm/chest--but it's hard to tell with your arms up. The suede jacket looks super luxe and pretty but I prefer the V neckline of the others on you. I like 6 too.

Firecracker (Sharan)

Veteran

I lean toward 2, 3, and 4 for you, given your comments as well as how they look.
Your history with jackets suggests to me that you may do better with jackets that really feel good to you and seem easy to wear. 1, 5, and 6 do not meet those criteria as well as the others. On 1, the fabric is making you wonder about its usefulness; on 5, the fabric doesn't feel wonderful to you; and on 6, the style is pretty distinctive, so I'm thinking it may be less easy to wear and incorporate into your style. I may be wrong.

The black leather moto looks good; it would be nice to see more photos of it styled, to get a better sense. But it seems like a very strong contender for keeping.

The suede jacket impresses me because you like the feel of it so much. Are you also in love with the color? If so, it may become a real workhorse, because you will love wearing it. Yes, it's a boxy style and very different from the others here, but as you note, it's more like a sweater. It has a casual yet luxe feel. Maybe that's something that has been missing in the jackets that haven't gotten as much wear as you'd hoped.

The JCrew tipped merino wool one seems the one that you have the least reservations about, and it looks good, too! It sounds like you will enjoy it a lot!

Julie

I'm no jacket expert, but i like #1 best!

Susie

Veteran

This is such a nice selection!

I got a Lafayette jacket and a long cardigan this NAS and the quality is so nice. I think the suede has potential. It's true that it doesn't have a lot of shape, but relaxed luxe is so nice to wear.

I love the VB Moto, especially that it's navy. I would have tried it but was concerned about sleeve length. If you are comfortable with the fit, it's a great jacket.

Of the 2 tipped styles, I actually prefer 6 as it's more sleek compared to the patch pockets on the other.

Jackets should feel good to wear so i would pass on 5. If the moto is comfortable and you've wanted it for some time, then it sounds like a keeper!

Joy

Veteran

This is an amazing line up of jackets that would each elevate jeans and a tee. Which feel most you? Just going by the photos I like 1, 4, & 5 best. Please let us know what you decide.

Jaime

(website)

Veteran

First impression without reading the details were yay to 1,4, and 6 but beyond that it definitely comes down to need, budget, comfort and fit.

Style Fan

Veteran

Great line up of jackets. It is difficult to tell the fit of the jackets from the photographs. Do you prefer warmer colours or cooler colours? I liked #2, #5 and #6 on you best.

JAileen

Veteran

I dress similarly in cool weather - jeans, tee, boots, jacket. These are all nice jackets. Assuming the colors work, and the alterations are doable, I like 1, 3 and 5 best.

troff3

I echo Firecracker in that #3, though boxy at first glance (might a smaller size work?), might be the most wearable, versatile and "special" of them all. Gotta love that supple tan suede! Of the others, I like #6 best.

unfrumped

Veteran

Wow, great reviews.
It's hard for me to tell fit in these photos. That is # 1 priority.
Next, I echo styling them. That might take me an hour or more but is where " the truth" comes out. Which bottoms, tops, colors, proportions. Otherwise I can acquire jacket orphans.

Jules

Veteran

I also prefer the fit of #6 on you rather than on the model, including the turned up sleeve. Other than that, I feel the jackets have different vibes making them not all directly comparable, and not knowing your style or wardrobe, I can't really comment as to which ones will work best.

julesegr

You all are geniuses! Despite the 80 degree heat (and the fact most of my winter clothes are packed away), I tried styling the jackets as I would wear them and I've totally changed my tune on some. See if you agree.
1, 6: The Treasure and Bond moto is fine and could be a real workhorse, but I realized I have a similar vest from them from last year's NAS (in Finds), so it may not be the best use of my funds. It also might look a little oversized, but I think I'm ok with that, given its style.
2, 3: The Rag and Bone jacket proved to be very versatile. These are only partially styled with regard to accessories, but it looked good both skewing preppy (#2) as well as more polished (#3).
4: The J Crew sweater jacket that I thought was a home run just looked bulky in my styling shots, as seen in this example I'm almost embarrassed to post. The striped T and the coordinating J Crew argyle vest were no better. It's being returned.
5: The Lafayette suede jacket, as I'd be most inclined to wear it (although you miss the round neck/snap detail) I had an olive cashmere shell underneath, for when I want to remove the scarf. It's very luxe but I know it's kind of shapeless. Does this help at all?
Not pictured:
- the VB moto, which basically looked the same "styled" as it did yesterday. Maybe I need more ideas besides a navy sweater or white blouse. As a result, I'm still on the fence. I plan to take it into the store to see if shortening the sleeves is even possible. Otherwise, I may have to pass due to that and the higher cost per wear I expect from it.
- the J Crew houndstooth. I like the idea of it (fab equestrienne) more than I like the jacket on me. It wasn't comfortable and it definitely isn't "sing." It's being returned.

Thanks, all! This has been a great exercise!

This post has 6 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

Treasure&Bond Relaxed Leather Moto Vest

$249.00 $149.40

Sale

View Info

Top Pick

10

unfrumped

Veteran

Wow! I love the shaping on the R&B tipped jacket. Much better than the JC. The suede-- it's a great rich neutral color on you AND you can add pops of teal, navy , burgundy, prints( as you did) etc to liven it up. I'd need to twirl around in it and see if I like it from different angles. Boxy- luxe is not a problem if it's a " happy fit". For a spendy item you want it to be versatile, easy-- good with trousers, jeans, light T or tank in fall, layer over merino in winter. So being comfortable and easy fit can be a plus. For me, I need to just be sure I " love " it and not go, oh, it's suede, it's Lafayette, my only chance to upgrade. That's how I made some mistakes with higher-end brand sales items. All that to say, i like what I see of it so far.

Firecracker (Sharan)

Veteran

The styling exercise is really instructive! It's great to see that you were able to make some decisions based on the trials. I think the Rag & Bone looks like a keeper. And I really like the leather moto jacket on you. I guess it depends on whether you feel you can use a jacket and a vest, given your climate and lifestyle.
I still really like the suede jacket. It looks gorgeous on you with that scarf. It's quite different from the other looks, and yet you look very at ease in it.

Anonymous

Love the R and B jacket with the striped top! Yes, it is much better than the JCrew one.

I really like how you've styled the suede jacket with the leopard scarf. It is a classic cut and a classic colour so that's why I'm not jumping up and down, but it could be a very nice workhorse. Maybe the wow-factor is in the softness of the suede.

The VB jacket --could you wear it with a skirt or dress? I think you would likely only ever wear it a couple of different ways, because it is the statement.

KnittingGene

Amazing to see how different the R&B looks in the two pics - both look great on you. I'm not that into motos (too stiff for me) but I just adore your look in the first photo - great styling. I agree with Firecracker, the suede is gorgeous and looks great on you in this pic but you'll have to think about if you'll wear it. I loved unfrumped's cautionary tale! One thought, if you have something more body con underneath the jacket, the boxiness will not be the full story.

shiny

Veteran

Without reading your post & comments, and just looking at the photos, the Rag and Bone!!!! WOW.

Will now go read the post and comments...

shiny

Veteran

Still R&B for the win.

I do like the Lafayette as well, especially how you have it styled. It's got a quiet elegance. Color works for you. I think I might have them taper the sleeves a bit (elbow to wrist).

And I might just try the next size down for comparison. Suede (like leather) will stretch, right? Seems you've got some room in the shoulders and arms there. So why not go a size down. It may take out some of the volume in the body.

Aquamarine

Veteran

I really like all of them as you've styled them. The first two are definite winners (wow), but they all work to my eye.

Banoffi

Veteran

I love the Rag & Bone jacket on you. You rock it! It looks so much better on you than on the Nordstrom model. I also

Greenjeans

Veteran

I love the Lafayette on you because the color looks like it was made for you. With the scarf it is terrifically comfy/casual. Without the scarf, it is stark.

Also, the Rag & Bone.

12