Put my order in this morning. Here's what I actually decided to try, influenced by Angie's picks:
Lounge Pants - decided on these instead of the pajamas, because I prefer to pair my winter loungewear with a tank top and soft cardigan.
Jeans - both pairs of Good American jeans Angie suggested. I'll only keep one, at most.
Scarves - Ordered both the EF and the Halogen cashmere wrap scarves. Would only keep one.
And some wildcards...
Blazer - ordered both the blue and black to try. Would only keep one, and I would only wear casually. The blue would be a true wildcard. The black would be more of a replacement, but why oh why, does the black look so shapeless compared to the navy in the photos? Is it the stripes?
Hutton Ankle Strap - to add a little "pretty"
Oh, and I ordered some lingerie wash.
What I didn't order:
I decided against a cashmere cardigan, as there's now a looming possibility of an upcoming lifestyle change that would involve a warmer climate. It wouldn't be for another year, at least, but, as much as possible, I try to plan my wardrobe for at least a three-year cycle.
Ditto on the winter coat, but I still consider this a wardrobe hole, and would get the right one if it came along.
The Frye bag was out of stock. Will stalk.
So, if I keep one of everything, that will be five clothing items. If I come out with just jeans, I'll be perfectly happy.