The black tops are absolutely killer. To my mind, it would be worth keeping the shorts for these alone - they really look that good!

13-16 are my favorite two...those shorts shine when they are dressed up! Love them on you!

17 an absolute home run

I have not read the others thoughts but the turtleneck is my favorite. The black tops are ok also. I am not fond of the others.

*applause*

for the homework. I'm impressed.

And onto the next item that feels 100%. FWIW, I loved #15.

I still love these shorts. I think the less snug/straight leg is VERY flattering and it gives the shorts a dressier appeal. With black tops, they are just gorgeous, although I like them with red and other colours, too.

I can't put my finger on it, but the shorts don't seem too *Mo* to me. Too yin?

I think of you in something more like this skort with the jagged hem:
http://shop.nordstrom.com/s/to.....s-_-1_24_A

Not necessarily in satin or quite that short, but the longer ones I found on the Nordstrom site were actually skirts and not skorts, although I'm sure you (or Inge!) could find other versions elsewhere.

Hee, Donna! You've got me. Or these, if they didn't have that same darn a-line shape and high waist http://shop.nordstrom.com/S/to.....egoryId=PP

You did a fantastic job on your homework assignment and can now make an informed decision with confidence! A great example to us all!