Minkoff bag: Should I duplicate? - YouLookFab Forum

Category

Shopping

Welcome! Read about what to wear and how to wear it on the YLF Blog. Join the YLF Forum to ask specific questions or just chat about fashion and personal style. Or check out the curated list of things we love in YLF Finds.

Outfits Ensembles Trends Advice

Minkoff bag: Should I duplicate?

Suz

(website)

Veteran

So, I told you all how much in love I am with my Minkoff hobo, right? This was a wild card that has blossomed into true love and may make me a bag lady yet. I've never liked a bag so much!!

And it was completely unexpected because I usually prefer a structured bag -- but everything in this one is positioned so I can access it easily. The one complaint that some reviewers have is that the strap drop is not long enough but for my frame it is actually perfect.

So. A very similar bag is now on sale at Nordstrom's in off-white. I love carrying a light coloured bag in spring and summer.

Do you think it makes sense to duplicate? Perhaps as an early Christmas present to myself?

One concern...if I had to set it on the floor it would get filthy in no time. I almost never set the current bag on the floor but occasionally it does happen.

Rebecca Minkoff 'Bryn' Studded Leather Hobo Bag

$425.00 $212.49

Sale

View Info

Top Pick

1

Rebecca Minkoff 'Bryn' Double Zip Hobo

$295.00 $117.97

Sale

View Info

Top Pick

17

Shopping

42 replies

Latest reply was from peacechick

Anonymous

I am the Queen of Duplication. Sometimes it was the wisest move ever. Other times not so much. I find that duplicating bottoms pays off; duplicating tops does not pay off.

So what about a purse? I would be inclined to believe that I would get equal wear out of a duplicate (and I love the idea of white), but I have a longer summer than you. Does that figure into your decision?

JAileen

Veteran

I used to love wearing off white. It felt very elegant. But now that I have grey hair, I find off white doesn't work for me at all. You haven't found this to be a problem? How creamy is the color? That could make a difference. As to duplicating itself, I think it's a good idea. It's so hard finding the perfect bag.

Suz

(website)

Veteran

Good point, Sterling. Thank you for that reminder.

I would tend to carry a light coloured bag from April to the end of September here...with occasional winter outings also. So I think that would give it enough potential. I just worry that it would get really dirty, in which case it would be silly to purchase. I have carried a light totebag but it was colourblocked with a dark bottom so I didn't have to worry about setting it down.

Suz

(website)

Veteran

JAileen, alas, I can't see it in person so don't know the exact shade. But so far, all shades of white seem to be working well with my hair. Maybe I'm deluding myself. A soft winter white is probably the best, but a not-too-yellow cream and a bright white also seem to work. Hmmm. Good point, though...

The light's not great and these aren't bags...but a couple of recent outfit photos with different whites...one is cream and the other a soft white. I feel as if almost all whites just pick up the white in the hair and make the outfit more cohesive? What happens for you? Is there a clash? Maybe your grey is more steely?

This post has 2 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

Maneera

(website)

Veteran

I have the same concern as you. I love the cream bag....but a large tote means a larger area that could get dirty!

For years I didn't buy a white bag simply because I feared it would get real dirty. I used to have a tote much much similar to this one you like. It got filthy after every outing and I soon gave it away. I recently got a small pretty white bag that I don't use often, but it's a small satchel, so easy to keep in my hand or sling from my shoulder at all times. As an everyday bag, white or cream has just never never worked for me.....light blue or beige are far more practical.

But only you can determine how dirty your bag would get (I stay in a dirty city with lots & lots of dirt & pollution). It's pretty for sure!

Karie

(website)

Veteran

I think duplicating a much loved bag is a good idea. Purses almost always irritate me so when I find one that is just right I will duplicate it. You'll just have to be careful about where you set it down. How much of a problem would that be? For me it wouldn't be a big problem because I could just hang it on a chair or put it on a shelf at work. That and some good leather cleaner and you should be just fine.

rachylou

Veteran

Yeah, I think you should duplicate. I think the Minkoff has really found a place and proved itself. You could put some feet on the bag, treat it to make it easier to clean...get one of those traveling table purse hangers...My RATE self actually has a couple of those and uses them!

Anonymous

A tough call. It seems like such a good bag!
Is your summer lifestyle the same as your fall one? Because you might not need such a big bag for summer.
Also, is your summer look similar to your fall and winter look? If they are different, you might need a different bag.

I might be overthinking things a little though

Staysfit

Veteran

I carry a white bag all summer and I set it down, in elementary schools, on the floor. Meltonian Spray! Damp cloth! Small miracle!

It's very hard to tell the tone of white from a picture. This one looks very warm to my eye. It might be warmer than you like. I know it has been fashionable to mix shades of white, but I still find it hard to mix a warm toned off white bag with my cooler toned white jeans and blouses. If it isn't a good enough match, I will not pair them.

I have a Rebecca Minkoff Backpack, but it is white, not off white. It seems to blend with both my ivory and white items nicely. I might hold off and try to find something in this shade of white.

Rebecca Minkoff 'Julian' Backpack

Sale

View Info

Top Pick

6

Suz

(website)

Veteran

These are all great points and questions.

Smittie, I seem to need a large bag always. Which is sad because I prefer the look of smaller ones! But it is what it is. I am often travelling (and need my computer) and when I'm not I might need an umbrella, or water, or a sweater, or to carry some shopping...happens summer as well as winter. This past summer I used an even larger tote bag and/or my backpack all the time. Only time I don't use such a big bag is if I'm going out for date night.

Summer look is quite similar -- at least my core style is similar.

Rachylou, now that is an interesting thought - a table purse hanger!I've never seen one!

Karie, I mostly hang my bag on a chair. But chairs with rounded backs are hard to hang a shorter strap from, and then in places like the theatre you can't do that. I can put in my lap of course.

Manny, that's good info, thank you. I really wonder...this summer my bookshelves kept getting covered with grit that was coming in the window...it definitely makes me think....

Suz

(website)

Veteran

Good point, Staysfit. And I know that backpack might be a good choice as well (and it's cheaper!) But it's not as large....hmmmm...maybe Nordstrom's customer service could tell me if they are the same colour.

Staysfit

Veteran

I was thinking of the color not the backpack. I am sure they could tell you if they are the same color.

Suz

(website)

Veteran

They're called something different so that suggests they might actually *be* different, now that I think of it. Ha! Hmmm. Still, customer service might be able to advise more on the relative tone -- thank you!

Jenn

(website)

Veteran

I think you should go ahead and duplicate. Treat your bag with a protective spray when it arrives, and just clean it up occasionally. Leather is resilient.

Style Fan

Veteran

It is a great bag and has served you well. If you have difficulty finding the perfect bag then go for it. The colour is throwing me off a bit but you know what works for you. One ink mark and how do you get that off. But nobody seems to worry about these things except me.

Suz

(website)

Veteran

Ugh...I probably should worry about that particular one, Style Fan, since I carry leaky pens a lot!!

Hmmm. My off-white and black colour block tote has served me well with no mishaps but again, it has a dark bottom.

Maybe I should go with a vinyl purse if I want white!

Angie carries light bags, though, without ill effect. But then, she probably doesn't carry leaky pens. Obviously I try not to carry leaky pens either, but I'm a writer and always need a pen and sometimes it does leak!

Angie

(website)

Fashion Stylist

(Keep the pen in a zip lock).

GET THE CREAM BAG.

DonnaF

Veteran

FWIW, I like the off-white bag for you even more than the one you currently have. . .I think because the feeling is more refined and less visually heavy.

Anonymous

I would get it if you need a big bag.
The bag is really practical and stylish and seems to really work for you. It is a gorgeous bag and the leather is really very nice.
I think the stain issue is worth the risk.
I also don't think it will get too dirty if you take care of it.
I'm an optimist today!

elpgal

Veteran

Love the bag. Perhaps invest in the cleaning products at the same time you buy the bag so you don't get stressed when it gets a wee dirty. Maybe a clever tailor can add feet or rubber treads?

K2

Looks like it would work for your wardrobe Suz and think of the extended season you'd get from it Victoria!

DJP

What Karie, rachylou, Jenn, Angie and K2 said !!

Elle

Veteran

I would duplicate. You love the bag shape and size and that's really hard to find. A light color should work well with your hair (it's not next to it so the exact shade of white shouldn't make a huge difference). If you use a spray leather protector and wipes you'll be fine.

Alexandra

(website)

Veteran

Yes, duplicate. If it's the right shape and color for you, I wouldn't hesitate. I mean, how often does one find the perfect purse? If the white bottom bothers you, you can always dye it dark.

Suz

(website)

Veteran

A zip lock!!!!

Now that is very clever. Or even a plastic lined pencil case. Why not? I have room!!

Okay. This is getting to be a reality here. Thank you all for the assistance.

JAileen

Veteran

I have never had a pen leak in a bag. The vintage Coach people sometimes clean their bags with baby wipes.

Anonymous

I may have to put all my lipsticks in a plastic baggie. I haven't had any mishaps, but I always wonder......

jill58

Veteran

Definitely get it. It has slightly different detailing than the bag you already own and you already know the style works for you. I wouldn't worry about it getting dirty. I very rarely put my bag directly on the floor and in any case leather can generally be wiped down. I own several RM bags and love them all. I don't think you can go wrong with this purchase.

Jaime

(website)

Veteran

Are you worried about the inside or outside? I will say leaking pens do seem to be the most common way to ruin a lining. Leather on the outside can be cleaned usually. Can you order it and see how yellow as opposed to white it is?

12