They're not for me. I'm very petite, so I can't really pull off the look, and even if I could, I don't think I'd be comfortable with all that fabric flapping around my ankles. I don't hate them on other women, though -- especially tall ones. I do prefer a maxi dress to a maxi skirt, as the dress is head-to-toe colour so it's elongating. Maxi skirts have more potential to cut you in half.