I ordered #1, which turned out to be on a decent sale on the website (but not in-store). I liked the shape of the longer Thornton cardigan, but didn’t like the fiber blend. The one I ordered is only about a 30% wool blend, but I loved the last sweater I had from the same (house) brand in a similar blend.

The EF sweater felt a little dowdy on, and was quite pricey for cotton. The Pendleton was too heavy. I’m still on the hunt for a chunky (or at least texturally interesting) duster cardigan, preferably in a neutral, since I purchased the mustard.

Yay! I hadn't got round to commenting, but that was my fave, pic was awesome.

My comment is the same as JenniNZ. Love that one! I also think Pendleton is a great choice.