April, I gave up on their pants for a couple of reasons. Inconsistent sizing is a big one.
Also last year I wanted to duplicate a pair of pants I liked, so I ordered online, and what I rec'd was like a shoddier, ill-fitting version. Which made me wonder if what is sold online is now different than what you get in the store?
I have also begun to wonder if ATL, to keep costs down, has been using new suppliers and quality and consistency is suffering. They've never been the best quality - it's not AT you are getting. But it seems to get worse and worse. You are getting H&M or Forever21 quality but *not* at H&M prices.
But the final clincher for me was when I bought these 0p slacks and took a photo:
http://s386.photobucket.com/al.....ylf002.jpg
They really don't fit me well at all.
I still like their skirts and probably 80% of my skirts are from them! I also love their jewelry.