#2 and then #4. #4 look cooles, but #2 is the perfect fit around the ankle and height.

without reading the other comments, I like the color in 9 and 11. That color seems to go really nicely and bookend your hair.

I love #2 & #4 the best. #2 looks more comfortable due to heel height & I love how fitted it is around the ankle. #4 looks a great match to your hair & not suede might have its advantages but I don't know how comfortable they are.

k,

I looked at your pictures and put, in order, which pair I liked best. Then I got to your post:

" I had #2 tagged as my favorite with #3 and #4 tied for second and #1 last."

and then realized that I have a unique and special ability to READ YOUR MIND. haha

However, after mulling it over, #4 wins, IMO, because it is NOT suede. I have a heck of a time and obsess over all the marks, spills and dirt that lands on my light-colored boots. I keep a Magic Eraser in my purse at all times just for that reason. I'm glad Magic Erasers weigh next-to-nothing.

I don't know how I got off-subject. My apologies. I vote for #4.

Kelley, you had me laughing out loud! E-media Mind Reader!!! I think I hear the CIA knocking on your door with a large recruitment package right now....

So, where did I wind up?

#1 is definitely going back.

#2 was by far the favorite. I'm keeping them...for now.

#3 was good, but is going back because #2 and #4 showed up and wiped the court with them.

#4 had something special that just grew on me. #2 was initially my favorite, just like almost everyone. But interestingly, the more time I spent with #4 and the more I looked at the pictures, the more I loved #4. And now I love them so very much.

Soooo, I'm seriously thinking that I'm keeping #4 and #2. Then I'm buying no more shoes this season!

yay!!!! a happy ending. you will love both booties and they will be very good to you.

Well darn, 1 was my favorite, but 2 is my second fave.