I like it. If you can reach your arms across your chest without it pulling uncomfortably in the back/shoulders, then I think it's ok that there is no stretch. I do agree with Angie that it would be good to see it open (I never zip or button my jackets!).

This jacket is really cute, but you said it yourself; not the one you were initially out for. So don't settle.

I think you look so beautiful in this! But... if you're 'torn', maybe this isn't the jacket for you.

I like the shape, fit, and color on you very much. If it's not a keeper, then keep the fit and shape in mind.

I'm not even reading the other responses -- it looks fantastic on you! I know I have a weakness for moto jackets, but this really does look terrific.

Now, only you can tell whether it will pass the comfort test well enough to enjoy wearing it. I say wear it with tags around the house for a few hours. This is what I do with all questionable comfort items.

Would love to see it styled a bit and also open. I really like it in the photos, but it sounds as if there are a lot of negatives to it as well -- so only a good play with it will tell you if it is "the one."