I haven't been in a fashion mood for the past few months... I've replaced a few essentials and picked up one statement dress in London (currently at the tailor after 2 fittings, altering a bust smaller is harder than one would think), but I need to do a wardrobe "study" for spring and I just haven't wanted to.

But I've been looking for a year now to replace my old Boden rain coat. So I ordered Angie's TT recommendation and it arrived unexpectedly today. I'm not sure if the fit is off, though? My body type is rectangle, secondary apple, and petite but I can wear regular sizes with alteration at 5'2 1/2". It don't usually wear A-line undefined-waist styles and I'm not sure how it should fit.

So here are some photos, in the hope that y'all can advise me! #1-2 are the Trina Turk rain coat in tomato, size XS, with the sleeves tucked up to the length that I would alter them to. #3 is my old Boden mac for comparison (hard to tell in the photo but the fabric is very worn around the edges, which bothers me).

What say you, keep or return?

This post has 3 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.