K/R these jeans - YouLookFab Forum

Category

Shopping

Welcome! Read about what to wear and how to wear it on the YLF Blog. Join the YLF Forum to ask specific questions or just chat about fashion and personal style. Or check out the curated list of things we love in YLF Finds.

Outfits Ensembles Trends Advice

K/R these jeans

Helena

Veteran

Hi all, just a quick question as I'm off to the mall today to do a few errands and returns. I ordered two pairs of Gap jeans and I feel I don't need both - what do you think?

- The dark blue ones I really like; I just need a size up. The hems are finished and the straight cut feels dressier to me (as jeans go). Also, with my dusty blue jacket, I feel these will function quite nicely as a dark neutral for f/w (I know I'm always saying jeans aren't neutral - call it a column of colour maybe?)

- The black jeans are a girlfriend cut and feel more casual to me. I like the fit (I have the same pair in white) and was convinced I needed black jeans, but now I'm not so sure. I'm struggling to think of why I would reach for these rather than the above pair. The only thing I can think is that they would be useful with blue tops in f/w, but I only currently have one blue transitional sweater, and one blue merino knit. I think if I wear these with another colour top, it's going to be a hot mess with the blue coat.

What do you think? Even though these weren't expensive, I feel I might be duping, and will just be looking for excuses to wear the black rather than truly needing them. Am I missing any considerations? Thank you!!!

ETA - I'll keep them!

This post has 2 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

Mid Rise Girlfriend Jeans with Raw Hem

View Info

Top Pick

7

High Rise Cheeky Straight Jeans with Secret Smoothing Pockets

View Info

Top Pick

4

Shopping

32 replies

Latest reply was from Angie

Tanya

Veteran

To me they are completely different because of both the color and the cut. Thus, I would personally wear them in totally different ways - blue ones the way I usually wear blue jeans (which for me are neutrals), black ones like a more casual alternatives to black pants, or for evening out, or for edgier outfits. Having said that, what matters is if you would wear them differently, or if you have a need for more than one pair. They both fit well.

Helena

Veteran

I guess good with a denim jacket in spring/fall too, which is a nice option *ponders* ...

Star

Veteran

I am very much into less is more at the moment however I also see these jeans as totally different and if not so spendy keep both as I am sure you will find ways to wear them differently. They both look fab on you.

Lesley

Veteran

Size up as in bigger? They look perfect to me! (Don't forget denim stretches.)

I am a big wearer of black jeans. To me they have a little rock-n-roll vibe to them. But plenty of people don't wear them at all. I think with black jeans, you're either feeling it or you're not. But for me they are in no way duplicates for navy jeans, which have a totally different feel.

cat2

Veteran

For me black is a neutral and I would keep, but if it’s not already a big thing in your closet I would pass, as it needs a different supporting act than blue.

Runcarla

Veteran

Agree with Tanya - two completely different jeans. I would wear the blue ones as ‘everyday’ type of jeans and the black as a dressier alternative. The black would be nice with your red sweater or (pink?) silky button down and sleek black booties or loafers for a pizza type date night or casual holiday get together. If only one pair, I say keep the black pair!

rachylou

Veteran

Do you have any other black jeans?

Helena

Veteran

Ok all - you've convinced me it's worth keeping the black ones - so I will hang on to both and we shall see - a worthwhile experiment I'd say, and not overly risky price-wise or otherwise.

Rachy, this will be the one and only pair of black pants currently!

Lesley, the saleslady agreed with your point - she suggested I just wear them for a couple of hours rather than sizing up as I do have a bit of room in the current size I tried them today and they fit well, so I blame the giant shepard's pie I made for supper last night for the snug fit yesterday

rachylou

Veteran

Oh, if you don’t have any other black ones, I say keep. Makes ‘em special

Helena

Veteran

Ooh, on second though, I lied - I have black joggers. But these are the only black 'real pants'

RobinF

Veteran

I see you have decided to keep - I think that's a good decision. They are very different to me, as has been said. I bet you'll like them! As far as size, I tend to buy my jeans too big because I want them extra comfortable. Probably not always a good idea. However I do think these look perfect on you as is.

slim cat

Veteran

Looks great on you - love both jeans! I'd keep black ones for sure - currently looking for one for myself ( for work and after ).

LaPed

Veteran

Both fit great, but the blue ones seem like they might be dupes, while the black ones would add a new dimension to your wardrobe. I became a black denim convert years ago and consider them more of an essential than blue denim for me. They're so versatile and add that little bit of edge.

kkards

Veteran

ok, i'll be honest, i don't "get" black jeans. i find them hard to wear/hard to style as they just seem so black. which is funny because i have no problem with other black bottoms.
and in my experience they don't stay "pure" and the fading black makes them even harder for me to style...but YMMV

Mary Beth (formerly LBD)

(website)

Veteran

I think these both look great! I'm curious to explore the "convinced I needed black jeans", because it sounds like you're on the fence. I think maybe do a quick style lab here?

kkards

Veteran

Back to add, I don’t see black jeans as inherently more dressy. But clearly I’m a outlier on that

Janet

(website)

Veteran

I think they both look great and I find it very useful to have black and dark blue denim in my collection!

Lesley

Veteran

Ha ha, I am in favor of any pants that let us eat shepherd's pie!

I have never forgotten the lesson from two cute and stylish gals in an NYC fitting room when I was in my 20s. They gave me the confidence to always buy tight for denim. (Like, not busting out, but tight.) Because the jeans are never as tight again as they are the first time you wear them, and then you're all, why are my jeans so saggy?

Anonymous

They both look great to me, as long as you wear jeans often!
I'm on team size up for jeans. If they're too tight I won't wear them and they will never stretch!

Sal

Veteran

I like them both on you, and the black with their lower rise and more ease feel a bit more casual.

I currently don't own black jeans but have, and wore them a lot when I did (black skinnies). Just a good change when you want the practicality of denim but black is easier.

DonnaF

Veteran

Does having lighter hair these days make a difference on how you feel about black jeans?

Helena

Veteran

Thanks so much everyone!

I think my concern with the black was more about my outerwear ... But I think I was overthinking it. My idea is to just give then a try! And I'll learn from the attempt. It's possible I will need a "true neutral" piece of outerwear to feel good in these in cold weather, but I do have outerwear that works for temperate weather. I also have a black puffer that will get worn when it's super cold regardless of fashion!! So I think I am happy to try.

Runcarla

Veteran

What…!! Of course black works with light blue!

https://youlookfab.com/2018/03.....ight-blue/

Runcarla

Veteran

…and one featuring a blue coat!

https://youlookfab.com/ensembles/page/15/

Or, this one with your blue coat instead of the green one shown!

https://youlookfab.com/2017/02.....rn-audrey/

Helena

Veteran

Ah great post thanks Carla!

Jaime

(website)

Veteran

They look different to me and the black pair have a great current fit for more fashiony moods. But I always have a pair of black denim around and wear them a lot, so there is that.

Suz

(website)

Veteran

I really like both on you! The black are more relaxed and casual and the blue are casual in a different way, because mid-wash, lol.

But seriously -- they both look great!

Brooklyn

Veteran

These both look really great. Good finds!

Stagiaire Fash

Veteran

The K/R question is hard to answer, because it depends on what’s in your closet. They both look great on you and are in line with your general direction, but I can’t tell if they’d be a useful add. Your commentary suggests that maybe you just need one.

12