Hello.

I'm trying to decide whether to keep or return these olive sneakers. I'm looking for one pair that will work well with the browns, greens, black, and blues in my wardrobe.

#1 - All Saints vs Spring Step

• The All Saints (on the left) are warmer toned and suede material.

• The Spring Step (on the right) are cooler toned and waterproof material.

• For fit and comfort, both brands seem good.
• The Spring Step has a slightly wider toe box and a firmer sole.
• The All Saints run very small and narrow, I had to go up a full size to get a proper fit. The All Saints have a nice amount of cushion and a softer sole.
• I can see me wearing either sneaker for a full day of walking. Both were comfortable out of the box. So from a fit perspective, both are strong contenders.

#2 - Today's Outfit
Today's outfit is from my pumpkin spice capsule with my Ecco's.

#3 - Today's Outfit with Spring Step

It's amazing the difference that swapping sneakers can make Angie!

The Spring Step pair perfectly with this outfit, the greens in the tee and sneakers match. BUT, I'd like sneakers that are more versatile than pairing well with only one outfit.

#4 - Today's Outfit with All Saints
Today's outfit with the All Saints. Do the different greens clash too much?

#5 - Navy Joggers with Spring Step
Here's the Spring Step with a navy outfit and a plain white tee so you can focus on the sneakers. Again it looks like the Spring Step work better than the All Saints in the next photo.

#6 - Navy Joggers with All Saints
Here's the All Saints paired with a navy outfit.

#7 - Black Shorts and Green Jacket with Spring Step
While the Spring Step worked in the first two outfits, do the greens of the jacket and Spring Step clash here?

#8 - Black Shorts and Green Jacket with All Saints
The greens of the jacket and All Saints look better right?

#9 - Tan Shorts with Spring Step
Again it looks like the Spring Step clashes with the tan?

#10 - Tan Shorts with All Saints
The green of the All Saints look better here?

#11 - Olive Pants with Spring Step
Unstyled outfit of olive pants with a white tee to focus on the sneakers. Do these greens of the Spring Step and Olive Pants clash?

#12 - Olive Pants with All Saints
Again it looks like the All Saints look better with the Olive Pants here?

#13 - Olive Pants with Spring Step - Close up and
#14 - Olive Pants with All Saints - Close up
Close up of both sneakers with the olive pants.

So I'm torn between these two sneakers. It looks like with some outfits the Spring Step look better, while others the All Saints look better. But I was only shopping for one pair!

What do you think? Is there one pair that works best?

This was a long one, if you made it to the end, thanks for looking!