Faux of course ..... I am a bit of a confused mess right now! I bought an H&M faux leather skater skirt (just above the knee) two days back. I love it. And then I saw this *highly elusive* midi skirt in faux leather in one of our local online shops. And I couldn't resist buying that too. Of course I love that too. Now I am stuck and I need help!

Although technically both the skirts are almost exactly the same except for the length, I could keep both if the silhouettes look different (They are not pricey). Or I could return the shorter skirt and go for a pencil skirt in faux leather (H&M had loads of those as well). Both the stores offer return credit and not cash back.

I have styled each skirt with the same tops and posted them side by side. The shoes are constant in all the outfits, and I chose the most flattering shoe style (heels and dressy). I could switch up the shoes, but if the skirts don't work with heels, they probably wont work with flats anyway. So here it goes:

1) With fluid shirt and sweater
2) With oversized tee
3) With fluid top
4) With lace top
5) With denim shirt
6) With fitted sweater
7) With a shell top
8) Column of colour and suit jacket
9) Column of colour and bomber
10) With fluid full sleeved top
11) With a short tank
12) For fun - a cropped tank which I use as lounge wear. I still haven't found my perfect cropped top. If this works, I would hunt harder!

I have tried to create the most flattering silhouettes. If these don't work, I am not sure what would!

My questions/thoughts are:

1) Which is the most flattering length on me?
2) Do you think I should keep both? Is it sensible? Switching the skater skirt for a faux leather pencil skirt is an option. Though I love the skater too. And I don't have too many skaters either. But pencil skirts is another story! But the versatility of a pencil skirt cannot be debated either.
3) I have been looking out for a midi for quite some time. And a midi which is edgy by itself is hard to come by!
4) I can wear this midi both low waisted and high waisted (stretchy). It has belt loops too, although I am not very big on belts.

Now this is a really hard decision for me. I would appreciate all and any kind of help! Thanks for having a look and commenting!!