I think once the sleeves are altered, it will be a perfect fit. The leather will relax over time. I love the color and the design.

Whenever I have doubts over a purchase, I'll usually wait a few days and try it on again with some other clothing. The initial euphoria of the new purchase is gone and I can analyze it more objectively. Good luck!
For anyone who is interested, the clutch was actually in the clearance bin right by the cashier - only $39.99! It's on the small side and won't hold my wallet, but it has these neat little dividers so you can still carry your essential cards, cash, cell phone, keys, lipstick. All I need really. And bonus is that hubby thought it was gorgeous.

The jacket discussion is so interesting to me - always something to learn.

Suz - I think we've been spoiled with "our" jacket in that the knit portion of the sleeves makes them very form fitting and we've become used to that look. The sleeves on this jacket are definitely looser but they are also more comfortable if layering a long sleeved top underneath. That being said, I'm sure they could be taken in some when being shortened if I were to pursue that.

I would definitely NOT be wearing the jacket done up - I know it is too small that way at this point. But so was my black jacket when I bought it. This does not concern me and isn't a deal breaker. The size up was huge in my shoulders and upper back so sizing up is not an option.

The style of the jacket is definitely more loose and "easy" fitting than my black one. I'm not sure that every jacket needs to give complete waist definition and be form fitting. Can having a couple of different silhouettes for different looks and moods be ok?

I'm not being defensive at all - please don't misunderstand - I'm just musing out loud and having a discussion with myself really.

Keep it coming ladies - it's all making me think. I'm going to play with it in my closet this weekend (with tags attached) with other items in my closet and see how it works. I think this will give me a better idea as to versatility.

The only downside is if I decide to keep it, taking it for alterations will mean the jacket is out of commission for 3-4 weeks and by then, it could be too warm to wear it!
I love the color on you Shannon, and really like the neckline as well. I think it is really flattering and would totally go for it if the sleeves can be altered. Fab clutch too!
Oh absolutely, Shannon!! Having a few different jackets with different silhouettes gives you so much more styling options, so I vote yes on that. And you're right, not every jacket needs to be formfitting and waist defining. And, as I said before, I think this style is great on you as well.

I can't believe you snapped up that clutch for $39.99! Have fun with it:-)
Once the sleeves are altered, and you don't wear it buttoned up, it's KILLER stunning beautiful, Shannon! VERY now and for the next few seasons at least. LOVE it.

Warning: Play around in your closet with the colour first. I like this shade of blue best with white, or black & white, yellow and grey, and denim. I'm not as fond of it with just black.


Angie - I cannot thank you enough for chiming in when I know you have such an incredibly busy client day. I truly appreciate your keen eye and constructive review.

I will play with it this weekend and even try and post some pics to get further feedback. I think as long as the color works with my wardrobe, I will keep it.
I didn't see this thread yesterday, Shannon. This is exactly the same jacket I tried on in mint green. The colours and fabric are just so beautiful in these jackets. I must say that it fits you a 100 times better than it fitted me.
I am not sure if this is "The One" for you though. i have seen you in far more flattering jackets than this one. If your budget allows, I'd say keep it for sure.
Ok, I figured out why I was ambivalent about this. I like the fit on you. I'm unsure of the color because (to me) it is a difficult color to work with. However, you are an outfit styling queen, so if you can make it work with five outfits, you should keep it.
I'm so glad it looks like you'll be keeping it. Angie to the rescue.
I came back to take another look. I can't wait to see a few other styling ideas.

My gut feeling about this jacket is that it can and will work for you. And as I said, I am sorely tempted myself. You are right about being spoiled with the sleeves of our other jacket; I find I like that snug fit and maybe it is why those jackets feel so great.

I also think it would be madness to go for another size. This one will certainly relax, and you are shrinking.
It reminds me of this jacket I pinned a couple of weeks ago.

http://pinterest.com/pin/27373510207707768/

Maybe you'll find this pic inspiring. I love the jacket for you.
I know what you mean Shannon, I went back to Danier to hemm the sleeves of my white jacket and also saw this babies, they are so beautiful and soft.
I really like this one on you and think it will look fab with white jeans.
Can't wait to see how you play with it.