Viva, they are old J. Crew. I love them, too!

Marybeth, I agree this color is fantastic for me so I am an keeping an eye for adding more of it to my spring and summer closet.

I also like 2 best although I like the color combination in 1 and cute shorts!

If the top is tucked in in 2 I might leave it untucked.

I don't buy out of season or far in advance of special events so so my keep/return criteria is pretty much "Would I wear it this week?".