Thanks ladies! I'm leaning towards keep on these... I think I can make enough outfits work for this year that they won't be orphaned, and will keep them in mind for future purchases... maybe think about looking for a festive tunic top that needs navy leggings. I also got the Sloan 5 pocket leggings in navy, so I'd like a few more navy based tunic tops anyway.

Funny how pants like this make you realize the height differences within the forum members... we all look kind of the same in photos.

I'm glad you're keeping them. I think you have a lot of options. BTW, I love your metallic oxfords, but I agree that these leggings look better with a delicate shoe.

I was shocked when you said you were 5'6" - I thought you were 5'10" or so. I don't know why I got it in my head you were so tall!

I like them overall but I think even longer tunics would be better. I'm not big on leggings that look like leggings though. Have you seen the Lou & Grey line at Loft by chance? Some nice long tunics there - I've purchased 3 of them I liked them so much to wear over slim pants/jeans.