Well, Peacechick, even my super frugal paternal grandmother thought a woman needed two winter coats when she and my grandfather were introduced to Canadian winters--one for everyday and one for "good". This was a woman whose entire wardrobe consisted of three dresses (two everyday, one "good"), one skirt, a cardigan, and two pairs of shoes (again, one everyday and one for "good"--"good" implying that a woman needs to look presentable when representing her family in public, I'm thinking). No boots because she wore those ugly rubber "overshoes" over her shoes in winter; how she was able to remain upright on those slippery things, I'll never know!

Oh, and that skirt was a birthday present from my seamstress Mom; its presence in her closet always led to her tsk-tsking about being so extravagant. But she never waivered about needing those two winter coats!

I'm glad you're keeping it! As far as I can tell, it will be your only full length winter coat that fits, so not extravagant at all. And who knows, now that you have such a warm, comfy, flattering, go-with-everything coat, you might find yourself going for more walks/outings!

I'd bet DH just sees 3 coats in your closet and, because he is a DH, doesn't realize that only one is functional. So now we're down to the red one, which doesn't warm your legs at all, is pretty casual, and is definitely a statement color. I vote you do that cull and keep your pretty puffer to fill many holes at once!

I'm glad you're keeping it because it really does look beautiful on you.

I think I have the "only one winter coat" mindset ingrained in me from childhood too. Why is that so hard to break? I've gotten myself up to one heavier wool coat, a thinner transitional wool coat, and a puffer, but I think I could honestly use one or two more, even for my much milder non-Canadian winters.

Hi Peacechick --

I know I'm late to comment but I'm so glad you're keeping this both because in your weather it's completely practical and because it looks so great on you!

I get the reluctance given the household frugal factor (faction?) but this coat will earn its keep fast.

Plus you can remind your husband that if you have to limit yourself to one man, you can never settle for one coat [etc!]....