I think they're really *you* in #4 & 5. I confess #1 was a shocker for me - that's a Santa Cruz look and I'm used to your L.A. polish (it is L.A., right?).

Can't say how long the trend will last either. I mean Birks are a staple up here.

I'm with Diana. I dislike the second pair, and find the first pair looks awesome on you!

Confirmation that only 'you youngsters ' can make Birks. look stylish IMO

I really like both of them. I think I prefer the first more "birk-like" pair better because they look a little tough and more current. But I like the second pair also although I do agree with (....?) that they do look a tad like a comfort shoe. But...I don't think you should turn them down because they show your whole toe. Be proud of those long toes!!