K/R Athleta jacket - YouLookFab Forum

Category

Shopping

Welcome! Read about what to wear and how to wear it on the YLF Blog. Join the YLF Forum to ask specific questions or just chat about fashion and personal style. Or check out the curated list of things we love in YLF Finds.

Outfits Ensembles Trends Advice

K/R Athleta jacket

abc

Veteran

Athleta rainfall jacket

Not sure on the length - see how it fits the (tall skinny) model (pic w bridge in background)

I will be wearing it over closely fitting items.

Idea is to have a lightweight layer for chilly mornings.

Please overlook the no makeup red face and wet hair pics. Took a couple more after I dried hair haha. Totally embarrassed to post these pics but I need feedback!

Note - it's very dark where I took the pics, sorry. The one pic over the bathroom sink shows the color better. Color mixes with existing wardrobe well.

Is this *my* jacket or should I give up until fall? The weather seems to be warming up now (though it would be handy on rainy days).

I also tried the Lucy option (last photo) but the elastic waist was a deal breaker as it accentuated my high hips in a bad way.

Feedback appreciated. If I return will need to do it tomorrow at the latest.

This post has 12 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

Gap Rainfall Jacket

View Info

Top Pick

5

Shopping

32 replies

Latest reply was from abc

Anonymous

It's very practical and seems to fit well, but I don't know if that's your best color. Are there other options, like blue?

Jenn

(website)

Veteran

I feel like it's a little long on you? Does it come in a petite?

marianna

Veteran

Very casual and practical. Not sure I like the front pockets when the coat is zipped. If you don't need a coat ASAP, I think you can do better honestly.

Anonymous

The light grey I think would be good, and the jacket fits well.
This is exactly the type of practical piece that everybody needs. I think it looks good. Hood looks good too.

Anne-Marie

I find myself wanting to see it in a smaller size on you! I love the overall shape -- it's so cute and highlights your body -- but it just seems too big somehow. Maybe it's the length, as others have said. And the arm length too? Ditto what others have said about the color.

abc

Veteran

Yeah, I have a nagging feeling regarding the length. I think that's the hesitation I have.

I think I like it ok. I want to love it but I'm just not feeling it, to be honest. Functionally speaking I NEED a piece like this, but I'm not sold this is THE ONE.

Xtabay, there is a green but to be honest the charcoal mixes best with my existing wardrobe. There was a lighter grey option but I didn't consider it, maybe I should (but given the fit issues maybe not).

Jenn, funny I thought the same thing. No petite, unfortunately. (and side thought - me, petite? wa ha ha ha)

marianna, thank you for your honesty.

smittie, thanks. Yes, it is what I need...but not sure this is THE one. Sadly!

Anne-Marie, smaller size won't fit my hips. I think it is the length throwing things off. I've envisioned wearing it with less wide pants, but still feel the length is just a tad long. wah, I so wanted it to work

I guess maybe I should return.

Anne-Marie

If it were me, I'd keep looking : ) I hope you find the perfect jacket!

Jenn

(website)

Veteran

Could you have the length tailored? I really like that color/texture.

ETA: I think wearing a slimmer pant beneath (as the model does) would help too, but is that really something you want to be thinking about with a gear piece?

abc

Veteran

A-M, thanks. I'm kinda bummed, but I think I knew it wasn't quite right. Thanks for the honest feedback and validation.

abc

Veteran

Jenn, that is an idea, but there's a back vent so I think that makes it more complicated. Oh, and the zip is all the way down in the front. So probably not.

Laura (rhubarbgirl)

(website)

Veteran

It's awfully long and a bit sacklike. Unless you really need something that's knee length for practical reasons (rain etc) I think you would look much better with something a bit shorter, maybe mid thigh, and a tiny bit better fitted to your shape.

abc

Veteran

Laura, I agree, I want midthigh. I thought this would be that length but it's reading longer on me. I usually don't have this issue so it's surprising.

Angie

(website)

Fashion Stylist

I don't think the jacket is a bad length unless you run warm. It's also quite a good fit.

abc

Veteran

Well, shoot, Angie! I had just about resigned myself to return it. I'm gonna think some more.

I liked the longer length and planned to layer with it. I kinda want to see how it plays with the items I intend to wear with it (as opposed to work clothes in a badly lit hotel room).

Sara L.

Veteran

I agree with Angie that the fit looks okay to me. I'm looking at your shoulders and bust and wondering if a smaller size would work. The length is longer on you than the model so I think that's going to come down to personal preference.

A question I have about your ambivalence - is it towards this particular piece or a light jacket in general? There are some things that are necessary in my wardrobe that I'm just not excited to buy. Black pants for the office are one such item - I need them to finish off outfits, but I'm just not excited to buy them.

abc

Veteran

Sara L - I think part of my ambivalence comes from the fact that the first time I tried it on I had loose fitting work pants on and the proportion was bad. Coupled with bad lighting every time I try on.

I forgot i do have some jeans and boots i can try with it later. Maybe I can try to scope out a bathroom near the lobby with better lighting Haha.

Anonymous

...Do you think the gearness of it might be throwing you off? I find it hard to love gear, although a bright colour usually helps to move it into the "like a lot" category. But you want something neutral....
Maybe there are some non-gear options that you could love?

ETA: This looks like dressy gear to my eye, and I find this category really practical but hard to get excited about. I actually do get excited about pure gear.

Suz

(website)

Veteran

I quite like it for the practical option it is. I actually think knee length is a boon if you are facing true rain. Is it rainproof or just resistant? And is that an issue?

Angie

(website)

Fashion Stylist

It's gear fabric, abc. It can't fit the same way as a drapey wool coat - especially on a curvier body. I vote try the jacket again with your gear under layers.

abc

Veteran

I don't think I'm against it.

I don't mind that it's gear, I actually am looking for something like that.

I intend to wear it a lot with black gear pants, brightly colored workout tees and bright zip front jackets.

Non-gear, not sure...I think this IS what I want. Just not sure on the fit.

abc

Veteran

Suz, re: rain. Not sure! We just moved. I'm pretty sure there is a rainy season at the new location similar to where we used to live. I think it's a practical option, for sure.

Angie: yep! I am ok with it being gear. I need it to be. My new lifestyle is even more casual MOTG than before. Excellent point about the drape being different than a more structured weighty fabric.

I may take it home (tags on) and see how it works with the acutual pieces I intend to wear with it.

Thank you, all!

Beth Ann

Veteran

ABC: I wanted the coat you're wearing, but purchased a similar coat from the Eddie Bauer Factory outlet (mine is black, and has a slight hi-low hem). I'll post a couple of items from their regular retail store -- big sale right now!

Beth Ann

Veteran

Here are the EB versions. I like the coat you're wearing, just thought these might be a bit shorter, in more colors, and the pocket arrangement is nicer.

Women's Girl on the Go Trench Coat

View Info

Top Pick

3

Women's MacKenzie Trench Coat

View Info

Top Pick

2

Staysfit

Veteran

I love all things Athleta. They produce workhorse gear and I'm never disappointed. I happen to love the length and wish I had something that long today for our torrential downpour!

viva

Veteran

If you can stand to try on some more, I think Beth Ann's suggestions might be worthy. Although I like the one you have, the kinder pocket placement on the EB versions look very sleek.

rachylou

Veteran

I really like this. I feel it's a good length especially if it rains. When the wrinkles shake out, I think it will be smart and useful.

abc

Veteran

Beth Ann, is the EB one lined?

greycat6

Veteran

I like the fit and color on you! The length is a little long but VERY practical.

I find this length of coat to be very useful when watching kid activities. It is long enough to cover you back side so that when you sit on metal bleachers (cold and wet) or stand on the sidelines you have an layer of protection from the elements.

I live the in PNW and my kids play a lot of outdoor sports (hello baseball!). I have two coats, of different weights, like this and find them the most used coats in my wardrobe. Are they the most flattering? No! But they are JFE and very functional.

Good luck with you decision.

abc

Veteran

Thank you to everyone who weighed in.

I think I am going to return it and try the EB one. I'm hopeful as the specs online say it's a good 2-3 inches shorter. Still bum covering but hopefully more flattering proportions. Shout out to Beth Ann for the suggestion. I will check back!

12