I like the Rag and Bones on you, but they look like a lower rise (more like a mid rise), so I was going to vote for the Paiges, since you were wanting a high rise. But if they feel too big, definitely pass. The Ayr jeans also look terrific on you, very flattering. I really like the higher rise on you; it's great you can wear it, for a different look. If you can use two pair, I'd get both R&B and Ayr, because to me they are quite different looking, with the different lengths of rise. The washes look different too--are they, in reality?