Thistle, I wouldn't say that Talbots isn't popular! Several of my friends shop there almost exclusively and they look great. And the things you've purchased look phenomenal on you!!! Very fashionable and well fitted, and that's the goal, right?
I haven't shopped at Talbots much for two reasons, really. First, they were always "grown up" clothing to me and it took me some time to move out of being a young dresser and into dressing more professionally. In other words, it took me time to move into their target audience. Second, their fits aren't that well suited for my body shape. Nothing positive or negative about that. It's just how it is. I don't have a pronounced waist. Their cuts are too tight on the waist for me or too loose on the hips, even their straight cuts. I fit Banana Republic's and JCrew's fit model better than Talbots. I'm sure there are lots of folks who don't shop at BR or JCrew because their stuff doesn't work on them. Boden is the same. It looks phenomenal on some of my friends and lots of folks around here wear it, but on me? Almost always a disaster. That doesn't say anything negative about BR or JCrew or Boden. They just aren't the right ones for me. I bet that there are lots of gals on the forum who own great Talbots pieces. You certainly do!