Looks good. It is the comment that Jessica's makes though about the riding up that makes me concerned about the small size.

I do like the red colour too but I do get that the stone looks better.

Jane - it does not feel tight at all from the waist down, my main concern is upper part - shoulders and sleeves in particular where bulky layers are the most noticeable.

I do have a light gray one that I wear all the time, but it is bluish grey that is not my best color and doesn’t match most of my wardrobe. Recently I added a few items in this stone/creme color and match-matchy me wants the coat too. But red would also go well with most, and will work well with my yellow complement too, I think.

Ahh okay. How does the back look? Is it possible to post a photo?

This is a back vew of smaller size with the bulkiest layers I could find.

And without bulky layers- how I would wear it most often

Another vote for stone color here. I like it with your hair. Regarding the size, I really had to look close to tell the difference so I would go with whichever is the most comfortable.

I like both colors on you, with a slight preference for the stone. I often find I long for lighter colors after the holidays, during the slow slog to spring. I think you’ll have to assess whether the small will be comfortable enough for the way you sit and move while wearing outwear. For me, I often regret getting a smaller size coat/jacket when I am sitting and everything is straining, even though it might have looked/felt fine while standing.

It’s settled then... YOU NEED BOTH! No one has ever looked better in this puffy coat!

The stone is perfect.. you have this almost angelic look in it.. the hair the coat. Love it!

Fit is great in the smaller size.

Yay! the back looks as good as the front. It is a great looking coat!

Thank you all. It is settled and I am relieved - stone in smaller size it is.