I love cozy cardigans. Here are a bunch of options. I get a lot of use out of these items, and have two to replace this season. I am willing to keep one or even all of these if you think they are 9s or 10s.

1-2. Vince Circle Cardigan. No pockets. Heavenly cozy. Good fit. This is pretty spendy. The most spendy of all of them. It has no pockets, which is a minor inconvenience. I think my main concern is the dark charcoal color. Is it terrible on me? Returnable to Bloomingdale's (which always gives me pause due to the sales rep). The rest of the cardis are all from Shopbop, so I can return anonymously. I don't think there are any more in charcoal, but here is a link. The model sized up to get length in the picture. Do you like this length on me? http://www1.bloomingdales.com/.....#fn=spp%3D
Note: all of the rest of the pictures are taken with flash as the sun started to hide.
3-4. Vince cashmere cardi. Lighter weight. Is the color unflattering?
http://www.shopbop.com/long-sl.....all-shopby
5-6-7. Free People Fall Friend cardi. Pros: lightweight, has pockets, cozy. Con: over 50% acrylic.
http://www.shopbop.com/fall-fr.....ll-shopbys
8-9-10. Free People Moto style cardi. Pros: cozy, has great color, has moto style which I've wanted for this season. Cons: same acrylic concern as above. Also, it hangs unevenly. Both open and closed, it is longer on one side, possibly due to the zipper or maybe this one is flawed. But I think I see this aspect on the model too, the uneven aspect.

https://www.shopbop.com/cuddle.....278024.htm

So what do we think? Thanks!!!