Thanks everyone for your insight. I'm sorry for my delayed response. The last few days have been hectic! The little "suspenders" I saw were at the Blues Jean Bar and are designed to keep jeans tucked in, so I doubt they'd damage the jeans. On the other hand, even though I loved my stirrup pants back in the day, I'm not sure I really want something underneath my foot as many of you mentioned. I don't think they'd cause too much bulk around my ankle. The boots I wear most often are suede riding boots with zippers.
I may have to get a pair of skinnies for my boots!
Maya, your response cracked me up. I can tell you think I'm insane and may be wearing absolutely awful jeans and boots. The jeans are very narrow at the ankle, Hudson straight legs, and the boots have zippers on the inner part of the ankle, so I can pull the jeans down that way. All in all, it's a pain!