Keep or return: striped wool coat

I ordered this coat online and it arrived today. I wasn't looking for a coat, but saw it in the sale online and thought I would give it a try. It would be fun to have a casual coat that is different from what I have already.

I like the style, the fabric, the fit. I was attracted to the idea of a patterned coat, and I like the stripe. The collar when worn up is too high for short-necked me, but I knew that would be the case, and I would wear it open most often, or not completely closed.

What I'm wondering is whether the color is flattering on me. At first I thought it was a bit too warm-toned, but then it started to grow on me.

What say you all? Thoughts other than color-related are welcome, too.

P.S. My adorable husband says he thinks it looks big, so it might be a return after all.

P.p.s. I added a natural light photo, taken next to a window.

This post has 7 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

3 months ago

Angie

(website)

Fashion Stylist

KILLER CUTE COAT, Sharan!

You will wear it in Seattle!

The striped false plain is a beautiful blend with your hair! Yes, warmer tones than you are used to - and stunning! Your hair has warm grey and taupe in it too.

The size looks perfect in that fashion forward way, IYKWIM.

That said, in #4, at the back as you lift your arm - I can see what hubs is talking about. I always think it's a good idea to compare sizes. So a size down would be interesting to see. That doesn't mean that this is the wrong size! It's "the look" - and dead right bigger like this. Especially with chunky knits worn underneath. It's a fit choice

Btw, you know that the French brand has opened up a store in U-Village

How cute is this skirt!

https://www.sezane.com/us/prod.....ork#size-2

Olive Green

Veteran

I like the assertive silhouette on you. And the tweedy fabric looks good on your skin in a dressing room? Wow.

Firecracker (Sharan)

Thanks, Angie. I felt it is a good oversized fit, so I appreciate your confirmation. (I did say that to hubs, and he was okay with that; it's just his initial reaction was that it is big.) It was on sale, and I think it's sold out now, so I can't order a size down.

And yes, I've been to the store at U Village in Seattle, and got a cute cropped sweater-jacket, the Betty Cardigan in sage. They told us the store is a pop-up and will be gone in March! Something else will go in there.

Thanks, Olive Green. That's actually my closet where I took the pics! haha!

That skirt IS cute, Angie.

Helena

Well I love it. And I think a little big is sensible so it's comfortable over thicker sweaters etc. Sorry Mr. Firecracker but I vote keeper!

Irina

I think it looks fab! And I love the color (s) on you.

Thanks Helena--I like this kind of style for that reason--no worries about what layers will fit under it.

And Irina, you are so good with stylish oversized looks, thank you for your thoughts.

Brooklyn

Looks great. I love the collar, the colour and texture. It’s a really standout piece.

Thank you, Brooklyn! Since you mentioned the texture, I'll add that it is bouclé, which is what gives it a kind of fuzzy look.

rachylou

I really like it and think the colour is very flattering. I do hear your concerns about it being bulky, but it's a style as Angie says.

Bonnie

I like it, too, and it looks perfect for cold weather. The color is very flattering on you.

Karie

I love it! And I think the size is perfect.

Aquamarine

I love it too! It’s a statement piece for sure. It’s nice to get some fresh outerwear this time of year. The lighter color, which I think works for you, feels appropriate for late winter. Size seems good to me.

avicennia

#4 is the only photo that gives a good sense of your skin tone against the fabric. It’s not a great photo and the lighting might be off. But I do understand your concern about color. I’d also be wondering if the color made my skin tone look sallow.

Jaime

Well I love it but must say that the jeans and your hair are a big part of it. So if I zero in on the coat I would say that I love the boxy shape with the flares and the vibe, but ok maybe try the smaller size? But I kind of like it a bit oversized. Great pick and styling!

Bijou

I love it and prefer this style to be a bit oversized - but that is my love of the 1980's coming through! Fun to have something different to wear.

Sal

I like it - it is oversized but that's the look.

Suz

I like it on you! I think the size is probably right, in that intentionally oversized way, and it is different from your other coats. Cozy looking. Of course I love the stripe and also the overall texture, which I think helps make the colour work for you. If you will be happy in it, keep!

I appreciate everyone's thoughts and comments. You are kind of
confirming my initial draw to the coat, and I'm feeling a bit better
about the color, too. I really didn't think that much about the oversized nature of it until my husband made his comment. Ha!

avicennia, you have a good point about the photos. I almost went outside to try to get a selfie, but something intervened. I will try to get out tomorrow and get a shot of it in daylight!

Bijou, I think this coat tugs at my nostalgia for 80s styles, too. I hadn't thought of it in that context.

Jaime, thanks for your comment. I will say, I imagine wearing the coat with different pants sometimes, but I will probably keep my hair. Haha!

Suz, it feels as cozy as it looks!

Lee

Active Member

KEEP!! Very jaunty! Looks super spiffy on you.

Ket

Oh keep!!!!! I think it’s utterly sensational on you! I get early Audrey Hepburn vibes for some reason. It’s very 50s yet 90s yet modern and now. I even like the collar flipped up on you. Though, it might not feel comfortable? But it looks great. I would reward your instincts: Keep, enjoy, and wear it for years to come. It has longevity, even with the oversized fit.

Dee

My first impression was Fab!! It might not be your usual colour but it still looks great on you with your hair coloring . Its neutral enough, cozy looking, perfectly oversized and its chic casual styling totally suits you.