Keep or Return -- Spring/Summer Tops

CocoLion

Thank you for your feedback on my last Keep or Return thread. I returned several of those tops, now I have more for your review.

#1/2 -- Silk swing top from Bar III Macy's.
http://www1.macys.com/catalog/.....26spc%3D81

#3 -- Another top from Bar III Macy's

#4/5 -- Peasant top from Willi Smith (TJ Maxx). #4 is untucked, #5 is tucked. Tag says "dry clean only."

Thanks for looking and voting!

Denise

This post has 5 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

15 years ago

Shopping

14 replies

Latest reply was from catgirl

kellygirl

Veteran

Lurve #3! What a fab top on you. It looks easy and breezy and oh so chic! The peasant top is gorgeous as well. It suits your boholicious style! Not crazy about 1 but I'm not very fashion forward. I know it's suppose to be cropped in front but it looks too short to me, IMHO.

15 years ago

sarah

Veteran

I really like #3 - it's unusual and suits and flatters you. #4/5 is also great on you. I think you're the only 'real' person I know who can wear elasticized short sleeves and not look wretched - lucky you! That dry cleaning business would drive me nuts - do you think you can just ignore that and hand-wash? What is it made out of?

15 years ago

rosee

Veteran

I like #4 and #5 the best -- really pretty. #3 is ok, but looks a little big on you. #1 /#2 give you a very funny silhouette and makes you look very "apple". I like the idea but not the actual top. Maybe find something similar with a nicer shape and return that one.

15 years ago

Lori

Veteran

I love 3-5 L-O-V-E -- definitely keep both. 1/2 not so fab - it looks OK from the side, but from the front view even on the thumbnail it looks too short and cuts you at place that make tiny you look wide.

15 years ago

celia

Veteran

The only one I'm not crazy about is #1. I know it´s suposed to be cropped but the porportions get a little bit off.

15 years ago

Angie

(website)

Fashion Stylist

I like them all!

(I like the white blouse un-tucked).

15 years ago

Aida

Veteran

Love all three for you, especially top two. I also prefer the peasant top untucked.

15 years ago

RandomThoughts (Andrea)

Veteran

Love #3 - so unusual and interesting looking!
Love #4/5 - nice and summery, but UNtucked

#1 - meh. I say return.

15 years ago

Aunty

Veteran

1 is a lovely colour on you. 2 is a great top, try with black or white skinnies and heels?? 3 is gorgeous, you have to keep!!

15 years ago

Scarlet

Veteran

I think it really depends on how well these fit your style. How do you feel about them?

15 years ago

rae

(website)

Veteran

Am I the only one who loves 1 and 2?? I think they are so edgy-cool. I don't mind #3, but it looks like a different person's wardrobe to me.

15 years ago

MNsara

Veteran

#3 looks wonderful tucked or untucked. Nice to have a top that works two ways for your mood du jour

I prefer the black & white top to the first top. (They both fall into the wide, breezy category for me.) It could be because the first one is shorter or that those armholes are so big. . . The second one looks sophticated -- like a modern version of a kaftan -- and it looks great on you!

15 years ago

CocoLion

(website)

Veteran

Thanks for weighing in everyone! I love the modern look of #1 but I don't think it loves me. If I had a really slim torso with a delicate bustline, maybe. I'm probably going to return it. I was thinking of the third top for work which requires tucking so that's going back too.

The only real keeper here is the second top.

15 years ago

catgirl

Veteran

I love the idea of #1 but I think it needs to be either longer or boxier. I know I've gotten mixed feedback on a few cropped items. Photo 3 is utterly fab! And love the peasant blouse too.

15 years ago

Category