OMG- KEEP! A piece that ticks all the boxes in such a beautiful way is a rare find. I think you’ll enjoy it for years as a signature piece.

It's a yes from me!!

I think a true piece with longevity - it is definitely you.

The only reason I can conceive for not keeping it is if you would not wear it enough- but I see this as a signature piece!!

It surpasses my high expectations -- you look fabulous wearing it! Love how it dresses up simple black pants and top.

Slightly separate topic -- I've really liked how you combine cognac shoes or bag with black clothing, it really livens things up. Have now added a couple of cognac items myself and plan to try out the look.

It is so wonderful!!! I don't even need to say KEEP - I know you will.

Oh, that is FABULOUS on you!

Absolute keeper, looks superb on you. It’s beautiful.

I’m not even looking at the other responses — I LOVE it on you! Keep and wear!

It's perfect!!

Fantastic on you! Brava for finding something so cohesive with your style.

KEEP!!!

Wow, I had missed this thread in the first place but am really glad I popped on.

That thing is SO gorgeous on you that it is almost enough to make me unbury my shadow style (boho). Fantastic.

I like that for you! And, I really like your cropped pant--super flattering, especially with the shoe.

I LOVE it! When I saw it over in my thread I really liked it, but seeing it on you I have to say it's awesome. Definitely a keeper.

Very nice, very
If you have where to wear it, it fits your lifestyle, like if you can wear it tomorrow morning - keep!

Nice! I've eyed a couple of Johnny Was coats on ebay. <3 <3 <3

Definitely a keeper! And plan something fun, so that you have an excuse to wear it as soon as possible!

It's gorgeous. You're keeping it.

Oh wow . That is unbelievably beautiful on you . Keep!

Y’all are so sweet. I didn’t want to influence anyone in my initial post but, yeah, I never want to take it off. I think I’ll wear it out to coffee with my maker friends tomorrow.

Emily, the cropped ponte pants are part of my work at home uniform. Absolute workhorses. The shoes are ridiculously weather inappropriate right now (I wore snow boots today) but I grabbed them to replace slippers for the try-on.

Ginkgo, I consider black and cognac a signature style. My absolute favorite right now.

Whoa. It's completely gorgeous, and very you!

Gorgeous, and so perfect for your style!

Gingko has it right-- "surpasses my high expectations". Truly stunning on you!

Gorgeous! I have a few Johnny Was shirts and simply love them. Take me back to my bohemian youth, but in a sophisticated, artsy way. I predict you will wear that duster often.

I LOVE this jacket on you. Not only is it exquisitely detailed and beautiful, but it is such a flattering length. You wear it well. I am so glad you ordered it!

Don't you love it when you can throw an item on with what you're already wearing and it looks perfect? This is so super amazing on you, glad you're keeping! Nice to see those Sevilla Smiths.

Hypothetical K/R, right?

Glad this worked out for you in terms of color and fit -- seems like it will be effortless to work into your rotation and a lot of style fun!

Oh wow - it looks like it was made for you!

Well wow. Just wow. Looks amazing. I am so glad that you are keeping it.

Stunning! The duster was made for you!

wow, it is perfect. Good you are keeping it.

It's an exquisite duster, and it looks stunning on you! How wonderful that you found something special that you will enjoy so much!