I use Olay with SPF15 for sensitive skin. It does not contain chemical UVA blockers, one of which (most likely avobenzone or oxybenzone) I am allergic to. This has zinc oxide and octinoxate (a UVB blocker, one of the old ones that I am fine with). No smell and does not feel "sunscreeny", just feels like a regular moisturizer.
ETA: This does not come in a higher SPF version though (the SPF 30 has more chemical sunblocks). 15 is fine for me, but I hardly ever burn (seriously, I can count the number of sunburns I've had in my life on one hand). At the beach, I wear actual sunscreen (I like the Kiss my Face one that E mentions above, actually, since it's entirely physical rather than chemcial blockers).
Funny story actually - at some point a few years ago they changed the formulation to contain some of those dreaded chemical UVA blockers, which not only made it unusable to me because of the allergic reaction but also made it feel gross and smell weird. I switched to the Target generic for a while (which was made similar to the old formulation but didn't feel as nice as the olay) and wrote a strongly worded comment (with some pleading as well) on the Olay website asking to please bring back the old version. Well, apparently SO MANY people complained about it that they switched back to the old formulation and now I am happy again. Moral of the story is - maybe you should complain to Clinique. You never know, if enough people make a fuss they might bring the old one back.
http://www.olay.com/skin-care-.....5609000980