Deborah, I can totally relate to what you're saying here and may I say that it's perfectly acceptable to want to keep company with ourselves. I agree with you 100% that I "feel" closer to some of the women on this forum than I do with those in my life who are "local" and that's perfectly fine with me.
I "run" closer to being an introvert and always have and was especially so in my youth. I still have a problem with small talk in some circles, unless I know the people or feel an immediate sense of connection or if a stronger extrovert type approaches me with warmth.
Generally, when I'm in a room with a lot of people I don't know, I usually sit back and observe and find one person with whom to chat. Then, it goes from there and if not, then I stick with that one person.
You have some amazing insights here from the others and I will add that we don't want to cloister too much and hibernate, so what I did in my retirement, was to find ways to reach out in a way that resonated with me. For instance, I started a monthly women's gathering, at my home, with like-minded spirits, and we gather for about an hour and half, no more than two hours, and talk about what's been going on in our lives, books we've read, health challenges, personal growth, etc. and it's all very supportive. It's a small group and no more than six or seven women.
I also feel close connections with some on Facebook and with some I've never ever met. But, there's a kinship that develops and I think we all need this communication, connection and "being heard" in our lives, if you know what I mean. Sometimes, we're not really "heard" and it's so important to be able to express ourselves in a safe, caring and loving environment.
Hope this helps you and also to know that your feeling is quite universal and common for some of us.
Hugs,
Vicki ^_^