I've always had a style that is a bit eclectic, though in my heart I want crisp, classic pieces. As such, I have also veered over the years towards things with a definite point of view: a sequined crop top, bright orange Nikes, etc.
But, I find over the years I've been able to settle on "good enough." These end up being the things that perhaps I didn't envision in my mind, but IMPORTANTLY, they look good from every angle and have an ease. Since I began settling on these "good enough" items, I have actually gotten more compliments than before. Things like a teddy bear fleece or plum colored pumas.
Your coat looks like a great "good enough" item. It might not have been what you envisioned, but I bet you'll come to love it. And like you said, you can always find another later.