Thanks for all the replies.
Marley, I think it is a matter of confidence too. I'm exiting from a phase where my confidence has been shaken in different ways.
However, it has been interesting for me to note the different types of compliments and how my presentation elicits different kinds. I'm still sorting a style direction and I've been wondering about the balance of conventional figure flattery and trends and the use of statement items and when I do/don't want to elicit attention.
I mostly dress for myself and have been surprised when folks make comments. For example, I like red, but red seems to draw attention and, as an introvert, attention can be uncomfortable. If I am feeling particularly introverted, then I can set the red aside for the day :), but I also think it is a good exercise to push myself a little.