I need help practicing for shopping the NAS! I have a lightweight, black quilted “barn coat” that I wear often, fall and spring mostly that I’d like to replace. It’s has a squarish shape, a bit below-hip-bone length, it slides very easily over my sweaters or coats and I can happily slide my hands in its pockets. I went to the Nordstrom website and looked at the coats currently on sale (I know this is not NAS offerings yet) just to practice my eye and judgment.

I collected the ones that appealed to me so far. The first is the holy-grail, quite unaffordable for me and not available in my size either. Of the other four, assuming they all fit me perfectly should I go for the details that have more impact? I do want a defined waist. Is the berry one too boring? My style persona(s) are (ok don’t laugh) urban minimalist and tomboy. I also like feminine details and a bit of edge. I don’t want to look like I’m going hunting, lol. Should I not go for black since I would wear it in the spring too? And if the original price is high-ish but on sale, should I assume it’s still decent quality, or decide when I see the item? Are the ones I’m looking at worthy of "Better/Fewer" or am I aiming too low with the brands? Please help me practice my shopping chops – maybe I will find something better at the NAS that would stretch my budget but within reason – I’d appreciate your thoughts!