Angie, actually, number 2 and number 5 are my faves, but 5 actually looks so similar to my current glasses, just with a bit of rim, that there isn't so much point in changing. Actually the fact that you are so enthusiastic about 2 put a big smile on my face. I was a little uncertain if the shape was okay, but since you think so, I feel reassured. I really like the color--it feels really right to me and the scale also feels good. I have a narrow face, and it can be tricky. Mr. Scarlet hates change Therefore his favorite is 5 because he calls them a "transitional look" to something more different. Yes, he cracks me up. So in your opinion the buck could stop here? I know you hinted for a long time I could address my specs, so I want to do it right now that I am taking the plunge.
Jonesy, I am so glad you like 2 also and think they look chic and modern, because honestly the shape is so similar to something I wore a good 12 years ago that it gave me pause. But those old glasses were black and never really looked that good on me because they were so harsh. I just liked the shape. SO, much reassured here.
Thanks to everyone for voting. It is so useful to hear all these different opinions.