I don't believe I was too hard on her. I'm hard on her style because it isn't doing her justice. I'm not hard on her body though--she is. She literally came out of the fitting room saying "I hate myself." Who can stand to hear their mommy say that? Not me! I too think my mom is very pretty and adorable and I really hate it when she says things like that (not to mention the influence it has had on me, but I won't get into that now since this is about her).
I'm surprised anyone would support those pants. They are too short for her, too wide, and they wrinkle like crazy. She has such nice legs that they are doing her a disservice. Even the color is something I could get past if they fit well. I'm determined to get her in some walk shorts this summer, but for now I really want to concentrate on tops since that is her main point of frustration.
As for body type, she is indeed an apple and she does have a tummy. This is just fact, it's not an insult. Lots of people here have tummies and apple tendencies but when they bring it up I feel like the responses are often a little insincere (not here but in general). Anyway, her waist is less than 5" smaller than her hips, she is short-waisted, and post-menopausal, so obviously her waistline is going to be on the thicker side. I always feel like I have to make this ultra clear because of this tendency towards denial when it comes to the apple shape, which to be perfectly blunt just makes us apple shapes feel a lot worse, like our bodies are just so bad that we have to deny what they really are. Well, the truth is that I am an apple, and my mom is an apple as well, and rather than denying it, we just want to know how to dress our shape, not pretend our shape is something else. That's all. Forgive my rant but I had to let that one out. I have it much easier since I carry my tummy weight on the lower part, just above my hips, so I still have a waist, but my mom carries her weight higher, and also has a big bust, so she has slightly different challenges than I do.
Bras: Yes she is a 36DD and just got some new bras so that's out. I think she would be disappointed with a bra gift anyway. Neither of us are really bra people. We would rather get things that people can see!
-Jackets: That's a default option, but I don't think it's going to be terribly practical in the summer months. I want to get her something she can start wearing immediately.
-Dresses: I only recently managed to get her into skirts, and even then she will only wear them for "special" occasions. I don't think we're quite there yet, unfortunately, because it would make my life much easier.
-Shapewear: I don't want to go out and buy things that only fit with shapewear on principle. Besides being uncomfortable for everyday use, I just think shapewear is sort of a cop-out. You're supposed to wear clothes that fit the shape you have, and shapewear exists to change the shape you have. By putting her in shapewear, I would basically be confirming that her body is impossible to dress the way it is, which 1) isn't true and 2) is going directly against my goal.
-Empire waists: My mom has the same problem that I do with these. They are just not for busty girls. I can still get away with some since my chest is smaller, but they just don't work on her. The waistband always hits awkwardly across her chest.
-Belts: Not for her. She would never go for this look, and I don't blame her.
My mom loves blouses which is why I asked about the black one. I actually like that one a lot more than what she usually wears (which all tend to tent out and look too big). I just wanted to know if I should use that one to give me a good jumping point.
I really wanted to get her a Sweet Pea top, but I'm annoyed to see there are no XL's. Going up to a 1X would probably traumatize her.